Something is broken. Something shifted over the last 100 years causing a dramatic change to the average man. As a young boy, the only reason I ever heard about Audie Murphy, one of the most decorated war heroes of our time, is that he is a distant relative. My father told me stories about him. Audie Murphy was an icon of male history, a true hero.
But something happened to our culture. Men with the character of Audie Murphy disappeared, and the average male metamorphasized over a generation. The men of today often lack the basic skills of daily living. They are increasingly immature, anxious, and depressed. They increasingly experience fatigue and malaise and are often bereft of motivation.
I’ve been practicing medicine for over 20 years. Each year, more and more men show up in my office feeling depressed, anxious, lethargic, and fatigued. With the backdrop of a pandemic disease like COVID-19, these men are more frequently suicidal than ever before. And, the majority of them respond poorly to medication and counseling. Why is there an increasing manifestation of malignant male malaise and depression?
It’s not their lousy childhood, crappy job, lack of desire, or failure to grow up that cause’s these symptoms. It’s not a lack of serotonin, dopamine or norepinephrine. And, it’s not even low testosterone levels. Although these are signs, symptoms and secondary effects of the primary problem. The problem is lack of honor. Honor has been lost by both men and women. But, this lack of honor has a uniquely deleterious effect upon the man. Honor can be learned by women, however, it is not part of their true nature. Honor is an instinctual subconscious characteristic found in the men of our species.
The feminization and emasculation of men, the emancipation and objectification of women, and the sexual liberation both sexes in our society has played a huge role in suppressing and repressing the need for honor. Though many claim we are “better off,” changes to our view of the sexes has removed our desire to hold and retain honor, especially among the younger generations of men.
What changed in the picture above? Honor is gone.
Honor is Directly Tied to Manhood
Across every culture, and across all of known time, honor and manhood are instinctively tied together. Honor has been and always will be central to a man’s masculine identity. Men would go to great lengths to win honor and to prevent the loss of their honor.
In all of classical literature, honor is the central theme because it is central in the life of a man. It is part of his subconscious identity. The poems of Homer, the plays of Shakespeare, the writings of the Stoics, the chivalry of the knights and the gallantry of the Victorian Gentleman are all based upon the “fields of honor” where men defend their manhood.
I find it enlightening that penned upon the greatest document of governance ever written, the Declaration of Independence, our founding fathers “mutually pledged to each other [their] lives, [their] fortunes and [their] sacred honor.”
Honor is foundational. It resonates throughout Christian doctrine as well. It is part of the Ten Commandments, “Honor thy father and thy mother…” (Exodus 20:12). Men have been commanded to “give honor to their wives.” (1 Peter 3:7) And, even God himself told the ancient prophets Isaiah and Moses that the fall of Lucifer was because he sought God’s honor, which is His power. (Isaiah 14:12-14; Moses 4:1)
What is Honor?
We throw the word “honor” around a great deal. But, if you actually ask the question, “What is Honor?” most people scratch their head and struggle to answer. If you press a person long enough, you’ll probably get an answer like, “being true to a set of personal ideals,” “doing the right thing when no one is looking,” or “being a person of integrity.”
Honor is instinctual in men. Men define their character around honor, duty and obligation. This is an inborn trait of the male protector and provider. A man will do something for his mother out of duty and obligation. Not because she nagged or pressured him, but because taking care of her is part of his definition of himself as a man. He may hate it or despise the activity, and he may complain about it, but not doing it is not even an option. Not because he is afraid of upsetting his mother. It’s because honor, duty and obligation define who he is on an instinctual level.
The Medieval period added “integrity” to its code of chivalry to temper “reflexive” honor (we will discuss this later). In our society, honor has been watered down and emasculated to the point that it is now defined almost identically to integrity. However, honor does not equal integrity. They are two different characteristics.
Even Mr. Webster himself watered down the definition of honor when he defined it as “adherence to what is right or to a conventional standard of conduct.” That closely resembles his definition of integrity, “the quality of being honest (doing what is right) and having strong moral principles (following a conventional standard of conduct).” These two definitions are almost identical. Yet, honor is not integrity. Webster’s definition above is not what Homer, or Shakespeare wrote about. And, that definition is NOT what our Founding Fathers pledged upon the Declaration of Independence.
Horizontal honor implies mutual respect of two equal men. But this isn’t the watered-down feminized version of respect that pervades our culture today. This is not the I’m a human being and you’re a human being and we should respect each other because of “social equality” type of respect. No, this is honor that is contingent upon an unyielding adherence to a standard maintained within a group.
Horizontal Honor hinges upon three essential elements. The first is a code of honor. This is a standard that must be reached by any member of the group to receive respect within the group. There are rules that outline achievements of the standard and rules that delineate how that honor is lost. Any definition of honor that cannot be lost, is not actually honor.
An honor group is the second element. This is a group of individuals who understand the honor code and have committed to live by it. Anyone and everyone within the group understands the code and lives by it. The members of group must therefore be equals and hold respect for others in the group, being both their equal and living and maintaining the standard of the honor code. Honor is then rendered based on the judgment of others in the group, and therefore the opinion of those members must matter to you. This respect is rendered in a two-way street.
These honor groups must be exclusive. If anyone and everyone can be a part of the group, regardless of their adherence to the code, then honor becomes absolutely meaningless. Egalitarianism (equality of social, political and economic status) and honor cannot coexist. Social justice destroys honor and the honor code.
Lastly, the honor group must be a tight-knit, intimate group. In a society of people that is governed by respect, a member’s knowledge of every other member and face-to-face interaction is essential. Honor cannot exist in a society where anonymity dominates. The rise of social media, and the increased anonymity that comes with it, chips away at the maintenance of honor.
Honor is all or nothing. You either have it, or you don’t. A person who fails to live up to the group’s code loses his honor. He loses his right to the respect the other members of the group provide. This creates shame. The recognition that one failed to live up to the code is shameful. For honor to exist, a healthy feeling of shame compels one to check one’s behavior. When one cares not for the respect of others in the group, honor loses its power to compel living according to the standard.
You either have the respect of your peers within this group or you don’t. Bringing dishonor upon yourself by failing to meet the minimum standards of the group (or showing disdain or indifference for those standards) results in exclusion or excommunication from the group, including the accompanying shame. Failure to conform results in your membership card being revoked.
The last semblances of honor can be heard among men in our culture today when they talk about taking away each other’s “man cards.” Men actually understand this at an instinctual level. Horizontal honor is essentially the need to actually hold the man card. It is recognition that you are a man among other men. Losing one’s man card is an echo of the punishment for violating the original code of men – the honor code.
Vertical Honor
Vertical Honor isn’t about mutual respect between two men of equal stature. It is about giving praise and esteem to those “who are superior, whether by virtual of their abilities, their rank, their services to the community, their sex, their kinship, their office, or anything else.” (Honor, Frank Henderson Stewart, p.59).
Vertical honor is hierarchical and competitive. Vertical honor goes to the man who not only lives the code, but excels at the code. Vertical honor cannot exist without horizontal honor. First, you must hold the man card. Excelling at protecting or providing then defines the vertical honor.
The feminization of our society, along with an insistence of social justice for all, makes horizontal honor in-existent, and vertical honor thereby becomes despicable, loathsome and to some, even “toxic.”
There is this feminist notion that masculinity is a basket of “good” and “bad” characteristics that men can pick and choose from. The pleasant qualities are things like provision of food, provision of funds, providing a home, duty, honor and procreation. The “bad” or distasteful characteristics are things like intense strength, lust, violence and furious indignation.
When a man instinctively acts upon his role as provider and protector, gender roles that are repressed in today’s culture, he naturally bases his actions around those things that bring honor. Being an honorable provider and protector requires the man to excel at those things that are perceived by the feminist as “messy,” “bad” or “toxic.” Honor is an action word and can only be demonstrated through action. When that man begins to be true to horizontal and vertical honor, today’s society sees him a “toxic male.”
Men thrive on admiration of their honor, especially vertical honor. It literally recharges a man’s batteries. These are the trophies, awards, points and accolades that come from distinguishing yourself as a provider or protector. It’s why men are drawn to messy tests of their strength, power, and manhood against other men. It’s what drives a man to run a marathon, become a prize fighter, learn martial arts, to be a hunter, build a home, design cities, write revolutionary computer code, complete medical school and residency, and on, and on, and on.
Honor as Defined by Our Forefathers
Honor as our Forefathers understood it was two-fold: respect from the group (horizontal) and praise from the group (vertical). Implicit in this definition of honor is that it depends upon the opinion of others. You may have a sense of honor, but that just does not cut it. Others must first recognize your honor before it can actually exist.
I can hear some of you say, “Wait a minute, Doc, honor is universal to men and women. What about the honor of women?”
Yes. You are correct. However, honor differs between the genders. Though codes of honor have varied across time and cultures, in its most primitive instinctual forms, honor was usually related to chastity for women and courage for men.
During the periods of history when governments did not exist, professional military’s were few and far between, and there was no one to enforce the “rule of law,” the moral force that governed the tribe and maintained survival was “honor.” Men were expected to act as the tribe’s protectors, a role in which strength, courage and vitality were essential. If the man was not physically strong, then he was expected to contribute through mastery of a skill (shaman, medicine man, scout, black-smith, weapons maker, shepherd, etc.) that provided benefit to the tribe. Honor is the driving force that motivated men to fulfill these expectations.
Demonstration of courage and mastery provided horizontal honor as men. That honor provided privileges of being a full member of the tribe. As they excelled at the code, the were granted even greater status and more privilege within the tribe (vertical honor). However, cowardice, laziness, and weakness were shamed as unmanly causing loss of access to privilege within the tribe.
Defending Your Honor
Defending your honor or reputation was a matter of life or death for many of our ancestors and forefathers. It is literally instinctual in the male. Even into the late 19th century, one could not get a good job as a lawyer or politician without maintaining one’s honor. Thus, to maintain privileges, men were highly motivated and tremendously vigilant about maintaining their honor.
Insult to one’s reputation or honor, or the honor (chastity) of a female member of your family, required immediate remedy. If you were hit, you hit back. Saving face was supreme. Retaliation was necessary to prove you still had the courage that made one worthy of honorable status. The chasity of a female member of your household could be remedied by the courageous act of the protector. Dueling was a common and acceptable means of defending that honor.
Defending honor can lead to what anthropologists call reflexive honor. This was inspiring and, also, problematic. When taken to the extreme, reflexive honor becomes an “irrational pissing contest” between men, clans or even communities. This could destroy a community. So, as societies became more civilized, they attempted to temper the male instinct to retaliate when honor has been maligned. This tempering is what brought about the honor code of chivalry with the Medieval knights and the gentleman’s code of the Victorian era.
A Man’s Honor vs The Group’s Honor
Concern for one’s honor is both selfish and selfless. On one hand, men want to be respected as men, respected in the tribe and desire the privileges of membership (horizontal honor). Membership in the tribe entitled the person to gain vertical honor and status through worthy deeds. One’s reputation for strength and honor also kept other members of the tribe from picking on them or casting them out.
A man’s honor benefited the tribe as a whole. Each individual’s reputation for courage and strength added to the group’s courage and strength. The more formidable a tribe’s reputation, the less likely other tribes would try to bother them. This is why men who do not care about the tribe’s honor are shamed by the group. Disloyalty of an individual puts the whole group at risk.
20th Century Honor is Depressing
In the 20th Century, urbanization and anonymity dissolved the intimate face-to-face relationships that honor requires. People have grown uncomfortable with violence and shame. Individuals feelings and desire have been elevated above the common good of the tribe or society. People began forming their own personal honor codes and refused judgement of those codes by anyone but themselves. This transformed honor into a concept synonymous with personal integrity.
Yet, the instinctual male defines his character around honor, and true honor has been whitewashed into personal integrity, the man experiences depression. Honor is the moral imperative of men. Obedience is the moral imperative of boys.
As a child, you did the right thing out of obedience to authority and out of fear of punishment from that authority. As we mature, we begin to recognize that our behavior affects others and the needs of groups to which we belong.
Honor is a moral imperative. As we age, we begin to operate and act out of honor instead of out of obedience to authority. Men begin to recognize that they have a role to play in helping the group to survive or thrive. Men recognize that their individual actions add to the strength or weakness of a group.
Honor in a Man Begets Love
The mindset of honor is different. When men function from a mindset of rules and laws, they do the bare minimum they can without being punished. Or they push the law to see how far it bends. When men function from the mindset of honor, they seek to pull their own weight, and then add further to strengthen the group.
Honor moves a man’s motivations to act from the base, childlike fear of authority, to a higher, nobler respect that becomes love. The love of family, love of church, and love of country are all borne of honor. A man will NEVER let those he loves (or himself) down by slacking off. Love, from the perspective of a man, is born of his honor and strengthens his honor.
If a man leaves his church, or is disinterested in and organization, it is likely because he’s lost the sense of mutual respect in the horizontal honor of that group or congregation. He has lost faith in that congregation’s ability to provide the innate horizontal honor he seeks.
Not only is honor a more mature moral imperative than obedience, it is often a much more powerful motivator. Social pressure, the very thing that drives honor, is more powerful than rules and laws in getting people to do things. Studies show that people are more likely to change their behavior when they think their respected peers are watching them. The key driver is respect of peers considered to be equal in group or standing. We are still social animals at heart – we still feel motivated by shame, loneliness and/or desertion.
Lack of Honor Breeds Ineptitude
Without honor mediocrity, corruption and incompetence rule. Honor is based in reputation and when people stop caring about their reputation, shame disappears. When there is no shame, people devolve into creatures with little inertia that do the very least they can without getting into trouble, getting fined or getting fired. This breeds a culture of mediocrity, corruption, and blatant incompetence. You can see this in any business or customer service network today. People no longer have any fear of their history following them and have no incentive to perform with excellence. Instead, we have a culture of employees with mind blowing ineptitude.
This lack of honor has resulted in a society that now relies upon obedience to rules, regulations and restrictions to govern behavior. The minutia of rules in your office, town, city, community, and state seem innumerable is because they are. We must now be policed by external authority to constantly check behavior in the absence of honor.
Honor Creates Meaning
The reason people tend to like old movies and books better than the modern variety is honor. It’s not nostalgia, or talent or lack of topics. The drama of old literature captures our attention because the characters had to operate in a culture of honor.
Honor provides structure to navigate and push up against. The struggle of moving up through a group by following a code, avoiding shame and earning honor.
The reason reality shows have become popular is that these shows create temporary groups of people experimenting with unique situations forcing the creation of and adherence to the groups temporary honor codes. Otherwise life is mundane and boring.
Without honor life feels like a great charade with our own self-constructed realities that lack comparison, competition and esteem of others. Life seems empty and insubstantial. Evil runs unchecked. Good goes unrewarded. True merit goes un-honored and everyone gets a participation trophy that holds absolutely no meaning. Everyone gets a piece of the egalitarian pie that does not nourish or satiate our hunger.
Arlington Cemetery – horse drawn casket for fallen soldier
Every Man Needs a Platoon
We are all part of large groups that provide us identity and belonging. You might be associated with a political party, a company, a church, a company, a town, a state or a nation. Yet these groups are usually too large to provide the intimacy necessary for honor to thrive. In these groups, no one really cares if you are living honorably or not. We must give up the notion that honor can be revived at the macroscopic level.
Initially, I thought each of us needed a community or congregation. That may work, but I realized the average size of a military company is 150 people. This is also “Dunbar’s number.” It is the maximum number of people in which stable social relationships can occur at any given time. It is the maximal number in a group in which honor and shame can govern effectively before rules and regulations are required to govern behavior. Interestingly, this is also the number of people to which ancient villages would grow before they would break off to form separate settlements.
Withing each military company, there are 3-5 platoons consisting of 16-44 men. Platoons are the smallest “self-contained” unit in the army. Each one has a medic, radio operator, headquarters element, and forward observer. A platoon of men usually sleeps together, eats together, fights together and, under severe conditions, dies together.
I have always been fascinated by comments made to me by soldiers when asked about their allegiance to one another. This was reinforced by journalist Sebastian Junger in his book, War. Soldiers admit they would risk their lives “without hesitation for anyone in the platoon or company.” This sense of identity, loyalty, and brotherhood drops off in groups larger than the platoon or the company.
Junger states, “For some reason there is a profound and mysterious gratification to the reciprocal agreement to protect another person with your life, and combat is virtually the only situation in which that happens regularly.”
Only a small percentage of those in the military are directly involved in regular firefights. The rest serve in support roles. Though support roles experience an honor culture in degrees lower than combat soldiers, it is of a more profound degree than civilians. Other than combat soldiers, police officers and firefighters are the only others who experience a similar degree of honor. They may not have their lives directly threatened every day, but they constantly work under the risk that they could, and they know that their comrades are willing to risk their own lives to protect them.
Where Do You Find A Platoon?
Not all of us can be a soldier, police officer or firefighter, even if they if they wanted to be. Yet, every man can, and should be part of a small, tight-knit honor group. This may be a sports team, men’s group at church, fraternity, professional group, etc.
If you can’t find one, start your own. It doesn’t have to be formal and you don’t need a lot of people. 2-3 people are enough to start.
For your physical survival and your psychological health, you need to be part of a group. Men want meaning in their lives, meaning that comes from being a part of something larger than themselves. But, if you are like me, until I understood the importance of honor groups, we are often unwilling to trade some of our individualism to get it.
Studies done decades ago showed that men who belonged to a group that was close-knit showed less fear when jumping from an airplane than groups of men who shared only weak ties. The studies demonstrated that men could also withstand greater pain from electric shocks when they were part of a highly-bound group, as opposed to one with loose associations. The military found that tightly-knit units suffer less cases of mental breakdown, depression and PTSD than units where morale and bonding is low. The reason for these findings is that men in a tightly-bonded group both know that the man on either side of him has his back. The fear of dishonoring their brothers drives them to overcome their own fears and move forward and not let others down. One of the men Junger interviewed said, “As a soldier, the thing you were most scared of was failing your brothers when they needed you, and compared to that, dying was easy. Dying was over with. Cowardice lingered forever.”
Men of Today Must Have Honor to Survive
Men around us in society break down and cave to depression and stress, just fighting their individual battles. I see it every day. They lack the strength to deal with life’s difficulties because they don’t have honor pushing them forward. They don’t have honor because they lack a platoon.
The core of honor, then, is this – to act in such a way that does not let the man on your right and the man on your left down when they need you most.
Conclusion
People talk about wanting honor. They desire the end, but do not want the means. Honor, then, will only live on in small units and platoons of men willing to accept and carry the burden and responsibility that must accompany it.
James Davidson Hunter put it this way, “We say we want a renewal of character in our day but we don’t really know what we ask for. To have a renewal of character is to have a renewal of a creedal order that constrains, limits, binds, obligates, and compels. This price is too high for us to pay. We want character but without unyielding conviction; we want strong morality but without the emotional burden of guilt or shame; we want virtue but without particular moral justifications that invariably offend; we want good without having to name evil; we want decency without the authority to insist upon it; we want moral community without any limitations to personal freedom. In short, we want what we cannot possibly have on the terms that we want it.”
Are you one of those men of honor? Or, will you settle for the pain and depression of living true to only a part of yourself?
Have you been cutting your calories and reducing fat and exercising your brains out and still not seeing the needle on the scale move that much? Persistently and repetitively performing an action that doesn’t produce the desired result is insanity. Cutting calories and reducing fat while expecting weight loss is akin to pouring water in the gas tank of your car and expecting it to run smoothly. Why do we do it? Are the 53, 000, 000 people with health club and gym memberships this year really insane?
This evening on PeriScope we touch on fat phobic insanity and the limiting step that actually turns weight gain on or off. (We knew about this in the 1960’s, we just ignored it.)
You can see tonight’s PeriScope with the rolling chat-box questions here at Katch.me/docmuscles. Or, you can watch the video stream below:
The only way to successfully loose weight is to modify or turn off the mechanisms that stimulate fat storage. For years we have been told that this was just a problem of thermodynamics, meaning the more calories you eat, the more calories you store. The solution was, thereby, eat less calories or exercise more, or both. We are taught in school that a 1 gram of carbohydrate contains 4 kcal, 1 gram of protein contains 4 kcal, and 1 gram of fat contains 9 kcal.
If you ascribe to the dogma that weight gain or loss is due to thermodynamics, then it’s easy to see that cutting out fat (the largest calorie containing macro-nutrient) would be the best way limit calories. For the last 65 years, we as a society have been doing just that, cutting out fat, exercising more (with the idea of burning off more calories) and eating fewer calories.
What has this dogma done for us? It’s actually made us fatter! (1)
Obesity Rates Around the World
Some may argue that we really aren’t eating fewer calories and exercising more. But most people I have seen in my office have tried and tried and tried and failed and failed and failed to loose weight with this methodology. In fact, the majority of my patients attempt caloric restriction, exercise and dieting multiple times each year with no success. The definition of insanity is “doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result.”
Most of my patients are not insane, they recognize this and stop exercising and stop restricting calories . . . ’cause they realized, like I have, that it just doesn’t work!
If you’re one that is still preaching caloric restriction and cutting out fat, I refer you to the figure above and the definition of insanity . . . your straight-jacket is in the mail.
So, if reducing the calories in our diet and exercising more is not the mechanism for turning on and off the storage of fat, then what is?
Before I can explain this, it is very important that you appreciate the difference between triglycerides and free fatty acids. These are the two forms of fat found in the human body, but they have dramatically different functions. They are tied to how fat is oxidized and stored, and how carbohydrates are regulated.
Fat stored in the adipose cells (fat cells) as well as the fat that is found in our food is found in the form of triglycerides. Each triglyceride molecule is made of a “glyceride” (glycerol backbone) and three fatty acids (hence the “tri”) that look like tails. Some of the fat in our adipose cells come from the food we eat, but interestingly, the rest comes from carbohydrates
(“What! Fat comes from sugar?! How can this be?!!“)
De Novo Lipogenesis
We all know that glucose derived from sugar is taken up by the cells from the blood stream and used for fuel, however, when too much glucose is in the blood stream or the blood sugar increases above the body’s comfort zone (60-100 ng/dl), the body stores the excess. The process is called de novo lipogenesis, occurring in the liver and in the fat cells themselves, fancy Latin words for “new fat.” It occurs with up to 30% (possibly more if you just came from Krispy Kream) of the of the carbohydrates that we eat with each meal. De novo lipogenesis speeds up as we increased the carbohydrate in our meal and slows down as we decrease the carbohydrate in our meal. We’ve known this for over 50 years, since it was published by Dr. Werthemier in the 1965 edition of the Handbook of Physiology (2).
While we know that fat from our diet and fat from our food is stored as triglyceride, it has to enter and exit the fat cell in the form of fatty acids. They are called “free fatty acids” when they aren’t stuck together in a triglyceride. In their unbound state, they can be burned as fuel for the body within the cells. I like to think of the free fatty acids as the body’s “diesel fuel” and of glucose as the body’s version of “unleaded fuel.” The free fatty acids can easily slip in and out of the fat cell, but within the adipose cell, they are locked up as triglycerides and are too big to pass through the cell membranes. Lipolysis is essentially unlocking the glycerol from the free fatty acids and allowing the free fatty acids to pass out of the fat cell. Triglycerides in the blood stream must also be broken down into fatty acids before they can be taken up into the fat cells. The reconstitution of the fatty acids with glycerol is called esterification. Interestingly, the process of lipolysis and esterification is going on continuously, and a ceaseless stream of free fatty acids are flowing in and out of the fat cells. However, the flow of fatty acids in and out of the fat cells depends upon the level of glucose and insulin available. As glucose is burned for fuel (oxidized) in the liver or the fat cell, it produces glycerol phosphate. Glycerol phosphate provides the molecule necessary to bind the glycerol back to the free fatty acids. As carbohydrates are being used as fuel, it stimulates increased triglyceride formation both in the fat cell and in the liver, and the insulin produced by the pancreas stimulates the lipoprotein lipase molecule to increased uptake of the fatty acids into the fat cells (3).
So when carbohydrates increase in the diet, the flow of fat into the fat cell increases, and when carbohydrates are limited in the diet, the flow of fat out of the fat cells increases.
Summarizing the control mechanism for fat entering the fat cell:
The Triglyceride/Fatty Acid cycle is controlled by the amount of glucose present in the fat cells (conversion to glycerol phosphate) and the amount of insulin in the blood stream regulating the flow of fatty acid into the fat cell
Glucose/Fatty Acid cycle or “Randle Cycle” regulates the blood sugar at a healthy level. If the blood glucose goes down, free fatty acids increase in the blood stream, insulin decreases, and glycogen is converted to glucose in the muscle and liver.
These two mechanisms ensure that there is always unleaded (glucose) or diesel fuel (free fatty acids) available for every one of the cells in the body. This provides the flexibility to use glucose in times of plenty, like summer time, and free fatty acids in times of famine or winter when external sources of glucose are unavailable.
The regulation of fat storage, then, is hormonal, not thermodynamic. Unfortunately, we’ve know this for over 65 years and ignored it.
We’ve ignored it for political reasons, but that’s for another blog post . . .
References:
1. James, W. J Intern Med, 2008, 263(4): 336-352
2. Wertheimer, E. “Introduction: A Perspective.” Handbook of Physiology. Renold & Cahill. 1965.
3. Taubs, G. “The Carbohydrate Hypothesis, II” Good Calorie, Bad Calorie. Random House, Inc. 2007, p 376-403.
Today’s Periscope was an exciting one. Do you really need a pre- or post-workout shake or meal? How much protein do you need? What’s the difference between ketosis and ketoacidosis? Is Dr. Nally a ketogenic cheerleader? Get your answers to these and many more questions asked by some wonderful viewers this evening on today’s PeriScope.
Be sure to check out Dr. Nally’s new podcast called “KetoTalk with Jimmy and the Doc” with the veteran podcaster Jimmy Moore on KetoTalk.com. The first podcast will be available on December 31, 2015. KetoTalk with Jimmy and the Doc will be available for download for free on iTunes.
“I’ve tried your low-carb diet, Dr. Nally, and it didn’t work.”
“Hmm . . . really?” If you’re mumbling this to yourself, or you’ve said it to me in my office, then lets have a little talk. You’ve probably been subjected to the common ketosis killers.
I’ve heard this statement before. It’s not a new statement, but it’s a statement that tells me we need to address a number of items. If you’ve failed a low carbohydrate diet, I’d suspect you are pretty severely insulin resistant or hyperinsulinemic. You probably never really reached true ketosis. I’d want to have you checked out by your doctor to rule out underlying disease like hypothyroidism, diabetes, other hormone imbalance, etc.
Nutritional Ketosis is Most Effective as a Lifestyle Change
Next, switching to a low-carbohydrate lifestyle is literally a “lifestyle change.” It requires that you understand a few basic ketosis principles. And, it takes the average person 3-6 months to really wrap their head around what this lifestyle means . . . and, some people, up to a year before they are really comfortable with how to eat and function in any situation.
I assume, if you are reading this article, that you’ve already read about ketosis and understand the science behind it. If not, please start your reading with my article The Principle Based Ketogenic Lifestyle – Part I and Ketogenic Principles – Part II. If this is the case, then please proceed forward, “full steam ahead!”
There are usually a few areas that are inadvertently inhibiting your body transformation, so let’s get a little personal.
Nutritional Ketosis is a Very Low Carbohydrate Diet
First, this is a low carbohydrate diet. For weight loss, I usually ask people to lower their carbohydrate intake to less than 2o grams per day. How do you do that? (A copy of my diet is accessible through my membership site HERE.) You’ve got to begin by restricting all carbohydrates to less than 20 grams per day. Any more than 20 to 30 grams per day will cause an insulin release from the pancreas and stimulate fat storage of both carbohydrate and fat for the next 10-12 hours, commonly killing ketosis. Keep a dietary journal to record your progress, your cravings, your successes and failures. I’m going to want to see it and review it with you if you see me.
No, I don’t believe in “Net Carbs.” Net Carbs are a sales gimmick to get you to buy “artificial food” that keeps you coming back for “artificial food” and halts your weight loss (you’ll see why shortly). You’re going to lose the most weight and feel your best when you eat real food. I do allow for the subtraction of real fiber, specifically non-cooked, non-blended, non-juiced leafy greens (If you cook, blend or juice a leafy green, it activates more carbohydrate availability). Leafy greens are real fiber. You can subtract them. In fact, I recommend eating 1-3 cups of leafy greens per day to help bowel function & provide necessary folic acid, but, everything else is “carbage.” Avoid it.
Yes, cottage cheese and yogurt contain carbohydrates. Be very cautious with them.
Alcohol also halts your weight loss. It’s not the sugar in the alcohol I’m worried about, the distilling process changes the sugar to alcohol, however, alcohol stimulates an insulin response after the alcohol is metabolized in the liver with a SIMILAR RESPONSE to regular sugar.
To Effectively Maintain Nutritional Ketosis, You MUST get adequate Protein
Second, this is a low carbohydrate, moderate protein, high fat lifestyle. N0 . . . it is NOT a high protein diet! However, so many of my patients don’t eat enough protein that they feel like it is a “high protein diet.”
Protein is essential for the building and maintaining of muscle, connective tissue and a number of other enzymatic reactions in your body. However, in patients who are morbidly obese [people with a body mass index (BMI) over 50], excess protein intake can cause fat to be stored by producing an excessive insulin response. In these patients we initially moderate protein. Excess sugars and a number of proteins, in the presence of a high insulin response, are converted to triglyceride (the soft squishy stuff inside the fat cells that make them plump) and stocked away inside your adipose tissue. Excessive protein, especially the amino acids argenine, leucine and tryptophan are common ketosis killers, not because they are converted to sugar, but because they stimulate and insulin response all by themselves.
If you don’t fall into the morbidly obese category (BMI over 50). Then, I encourage you to use the protein levels below.
Initially, I ask my patients to focus on lowering their carbohydrate intake and I don’t really worry about protein. (It is often hard enough to figure out what the difference between a carbohydrate and a protein in the first month or two if you’ve never had any nutrition background.) Most people begin losing weight just by lowering carbohydrates over the first few months. Once you figure out how to lower your carbohydrates, if your weight loss is not moving and your pants are not getting looser, then you’re probably eating too much protein.
How much protein do you need? It’s pretty easy to calculate and is based on your height and gender. Your basic protein needs to maintain muscle, skin and hair growth are as follows:
70 grams or higher for women per day
120 grams or higher for men per day.
However, these levels are WAY TOO LOW for weight loss and maintaining good health. Because we now know that protein acts as a hormone in a number of ways, in my office I recommend women get 80-90 grams of protein per day, and men should get > 150 grams of protein per day.
This also goes for protein powders and protein shakes. Many of these have 25-40 grams of protein in them per serving, so be careful with their use.
Nutritional Ketosis is a High Fat Diet
Third, this is a high fat lifestyle. Yes, I want you to INCREASE your fat intake. I’m going to repeat that, again, just for clarity, . . . . INCREASE your fat intake. Increase it to around 50% of your total calories, . . . 70% of your total calories if you can do it. Not enough fat is a common ketosis killer.
“What?! Won’t that cause heart disease and stroke and make my cholesterol worse?!!!”
I know, take a big deep breath . . . (you may even need to breath into a paper bag for a minute if you begin hyperventilating).
No, it will not raise your cholesterol, cause heart disease, or cause a stroke. If you have lowered your carbohydrate intake to less than 20 grams per day, then there is NO hormonal signal for you to make more bad cholesterol, worsen heart disease, or cause a stroke. In fact, there is great data showing that increasing your fat and lowering your carbohydrates reverses the blockage in the arteries. I see this reversal every single day in my clinic through the application of ketogenic diets.
If we remove carbohydrate as your primary fuel, you must replace it with something else.That something else should be fat. Protein must be moderated, as it will also be stored as fat if you eat too much. So, if the carbohydrates are kept low, fat intake can be increased and the body will pick the fat it wants and essentially throw the rest out without raising cholesterol, causing weight gain or causing heart disease. This is why we want you to use good natural animal fats like butter, hard cheese, olive oil, coconut oil, avocado, etc. Look for fats highest in omega-3 fatty acids as these decrease inflammation and improved weight loss. Look for meats highest in fat like red meat (55% fat) and pork (45% fat). Take the food pyramid and flip it over.
Check Your Sweeteners At the Door
The fourth common ketosis killer and culprit in halting your weight loss is artificial sweeteners. There are quite a few of them. Most of them WILL cause an insulin response (exactly what we don’t want for weight loss) with minimal to no rise in blood sugar. Raising blood sugar doesn’t matter, if the insulin is being stimulated . . . “you’re gonna gain weight for the next 10-12 hours.” I wrote an article for you to print off and hang on your fridge, upload it to your iPhone or carry it with you in your purse to the grocery store. (If you’re a man and you’re carrying a purse, please don’t tell me about it.) You can find the article here: The Skinny About Sweeteners. The short list of those sweeteners that are OK to use and cook with, and do not increase insulin response, can be found here in my Amazon Store.
Don’t Even Start with Coffee Creamers
Fifth on my list is coffee creamer. Coffee creamer contains corn syrup solids (another very special name for . . . SUGAR!!) and/or maltodextrin (SUGAR’s married name!). If you must put something in your coffee, then use real heavy cream (pure tasty fat) or real butter. It will taste much better (I’m told – I don’t drink coffee personally) and you won’t get an insulin spike 2-3 hours later and begin craving more coffee and donuts.
Yes, “Half & Half” is half fat and half sugar. . . avoid it too!!
Ketosis Killing Medications
The sixth culprit in halting weight loss is medications. Please talk to your doctor before making ANY changes in your medications as suddently stopping them can be hazardous to your health. Those highest on my list for stopping your weight loss are Glyburide (glipizide), insulin, & steroids like prednisone. A more complete list of medications that will halt your weight loss can be found on my on my ketogenic diet plan. If you are on any prescription medications, please talk to your doctor or to a physician board certified in obesity medicine treatment about how to adjust or wean these medications in a way that is safe and appropriate for your individual needs.
Estrogen
The seventh common culprit in halting weight loss is a lack of estrogen in menopausal or post-menopausal women. About 20% of women that I see in my practice who are over 55 years old, need some degree of estrogen replacement before they are able to lose weight. Estrogen plays a very large role in regulation of the metabolism and when deficient, causes weight retention or weight gain. Talk to your doctor about the risks and benefits of estrogen for you individually in this situation.
For many years, we’ve thought that caffeine was great for weight loss. However, we are finding, clinically, that too much caffeine can also cause a stress response by raising cortisol, releasing glycogen, thereby stimulating an insulin response and bringing your weight loss to a screeching halt. How much caffeine? . . . The jury is still out . . . and remains to be determined. But, I am currently under going an n=1 experiment on myself (as many of you know, I loved Diet Dr. Pepper. But I had to give it up). I’ll keep you posted . . .
Look closely at these eight issues. Correcting them usually solves most plateaus with weight loss and improves blood pressure, blood sugar and cholesterol control dramatically.
This evening on PeriScope, we talked about the 10 things you can do to stay motivated on your low-carb lifestyle. A number of great questions were asked including:
How much carbohydrate should be restricted?
What labs should you be monitoring regularly?
What’s a normal blood sugar?
Why is Dr. Nally freezing in Denver?
Is fermented food good for you?
Why should you eat pickles and kimchi even when you’re not pregnant?
And, much much more . . . It’s like a college ketogenic course on overdrive . . . for FREE!!!
You can see the PeriScope with the comments rolling in real-time here: katch.me/docmuscles
There are three constants in life: change, choice & principles. Change, ironically acting as a constant, is the variable that we have limited control over. Accepting that change is going to happen, that change is constant, and making choices to prepare for those changes is the key to success. My last post introduced the 10 Principles of the Ketogenic Lifestyle. This post will discuss choice as a foundation for those principles outlined in the ketogenic lifestyle. Choices are directly influenced by the balance between the mind, the body and the spirit of man.
LIFESTYLE PRINCIPLE 1 – WHEREVER YOU GO, THERE YOU ARE
People seem to get sidetracked off a ketogenic lifestyle for a number of reasons, but the most common I hear is that they were traveling, had company visit or they were on vacation. Successfully living a lifestyle requires that you first know who you are and where you are before you can consistently make good, solid, principle based choices. So I ask, who are you? Are you defined by your job, by your finances, by your travels, by your friends or by your vacations? Each of these experiences is unique. Our experiences place both good and bad before us. I have come to learn over time and countless interactions with people that nothing is coincidental. Everything, good and bad, happen for a reason.
Today’s society teaches the Pleasure Principle. This is the human instinct to seek pleasure and avoid pain, including avoiding painful recollections. We often define ourselves by those things that bring us pleasure. We each go through personal tests, failures and triumphs. Some of us harness all of those experiences for good, others find worsening mental paralysis due to fear of them. We often hide from the painful experiences and attempt to bury or forget them. Food is often involved with many of the experiences of life, and for a significant number of people, the endorphin release from eating a meal, sometimes just the act of chewing, may be the only pleasure one experience in a day, in a week or a in a year. Many people hide from painful recollections behind the simple pleasure produced by the eating of “comfort foods.” Food, and our opportunities to experience pleasure from it’s various flavors, textures and physical stimulus, begin to define us. However, hiding from life’s painful memories with momentary pleasures usually prolongs or makes the problem worse. The ingestion of simple foods containing glucose and fructose, their effect on the liver, and the hedonistic hormonal response is the basis of addiction, and simple carbohydrates provide the perfect fix.
Fascinatingly, when fructose is metabolized in the liver, in the presence of glucose (the basic structure of sugar – one fructose molecule bound to a glucose molecule), the byproduct has a hedonic (pleasure experiencing) effect on the exact same pleasure receptors in the brain that bind to morphine. Yes, that’s why the M&M’s make you forget your troubles and why the Jolly Rancher is so jolly. And, its the same reason you crave another do-nut two hours after you ate the entire baker’s dozen.
Although obesity has been recognized as a disease, our use of foods to celebrate with people or events in life is still a form of pleasure seeking. Excuses to deviate from healthy behavior under the guise of family, vacation, or social requirements, acknowledges our willingness to hide from pain with hedonic drugs like chocolate chip cookies and cotton candy. In fact, it’s usually a welcomed and and expected acceptable excuse.
“Dr. Nally, I can cheat eat and bad, (meals loaded with starch) because I’m on vacation” . . . from my problems. It’s so acceptable, we’ve based movie themes around it.
Healing can only occur when one is willing to confront and talk about the reasons, the real reasons you’d rather experience the endorphins from the do-nuts with your family instead of acknowledge your weakness, stresses, and fears. Many of us are so afraid of where we might be, we avoid acknowledging where and who we are. It takes courage not to take the easy path. And I will be the first to admit, pizza is the easy path and it’s scenic views are decorated with french fry palms and sunset clouds of apple fritters.
“There appears to be a conscience in mankind which severely punishes the man who does not somehow and at some time, at whatever cost to his pride, cease to defend and assert himself, and instead confess himself fallible and human. Until he can do this, an impenetrable wall shuts him out from the living experience of feeling himself a man among men. Here we find a key to the great significance of true, un-stereotyped confession – a significance known in all the initiation and mystery cults of the ancient world, as is shown by a saying from the Greek mysteries: “Give up what thou hast, and thou will receive.” (Carl Jung)
We have a choice about what to eat and when to eat, however, each choice has a reward and/or a consequence.
Points of Focus: Where are you and what are you hiding from? Sharing your weaknesses actually empowers you you overcome them. This can often be accomplished through the simple act of journaling, planing your meals the day before and journaling your successes and failures in that plan the following day. Allowing yourself and others insight into your times of weakness actually brings strength. It allows one to look at the reasons for food choices base on how you feel, and how you felt after the choice. If forces one to think about a choice before it ever has to be made. In my 15 years of medical practice, I have yet to hear a child find fault with a parent who worked tirelessly to make ends meet, admittedly struggled with alcoholism, battled against disease or fought against belittling for a belief. The child has always expressed their admiration of their parent’s courage and understanding of why decisions were made, even when erroneous. It takes courage to admit that wherever you go – there you are.
LIFESTYLE PRINCIPLE 2 – KEEP IT REAL
I no longer believe in coincidence. Whether you have thought about it or not, every interaction you have with others (even our interaction . . . your reading this blog), are not by coincidence. There is a reason. Whether you believe it or not, everything around us testifies that God exists; the Hand of Providence can be seen from the rotation of the earth, planets and stars, the precision of the seasons, the balance of the atmosphere allowing for the perfect pressures and concentration of elements to sustain a life giving breath, to the perfect replication of DNA within billions of cells throughout the body. I’m not trying to get religious, and, no, I can’t prove this through the scientific method . . . But, if the Big Bang started the universe, what started the Big Bang? Where did the first atom or molecule or particle of dust come from? I have a very difficult time accepting that you and I are here by accident, by a chaotic explosion that created order. That implies that there must be a plan, and that plan had to have been set in motion by a Creator. That also implies that that Creator placed solutions to our challenges, including the diseases of civilization, within our grasp and available to those seeking the solutions upon the earth today.
I have seen enough in my medical career to know that simple coincidence has frequently become significantly important, life changing and often life saving. This does not happen by accident and screams loud and clear that there is a plan for you and me. No good father would lock his child in a room without doors or windows or any escape without everything in the room, both good and bad, pointing to the reason the child was in the room, and pointing the way for the child to become his or her best self, physically and emotionally. Life has meaning. It is supposed to. If we get off track, coincidence and interactions lead us back.
“Behold, the hour cometh, yea, is now come, that ye shall be scattered, every man to his own, and shall leave me alone: and yet I am not alone because the Father is with me.” (John 16:32)
The Bible, among other records, records the voices of men and women from years past transcribing their experiences with the Hand of Providence, how that spiritual void was filled, how it helped the with choice and how our lives have deeper meaning and consequence, even amidst significant adversity.
Take a week and look at the synchronicity of your life. Journal about it. Don’t dismiss a second invitation from someone to discuss an opportunity or meet someone your friend thinks could be important to you, open that book that someone left behind on the subway seat beside you. Don’t assume it is meaningless, that some kind person returned your sunglasses or your wallet. Look at the simple interactions and recent relationships. These are the breadcrumbs and the street signs from a loving Creator, a loving Father.
Keeping it real means nothing less than complete authenticity. The last place you want to be is in the first-class seat on the plane to no-where. Have the faith to get off the plane and take the bus, ride your bike, or even swim upstream in the direction you’re supposed to be going. Look for the coincidences, bread crumbs and spiritual street signs in your life.
How does this relate to a ketogenic lifestyle? Every religion or spiritual tradition speaks of a polestar. The polestar is that anchor to which the entire solar system is tied by invisible aerial chords and the engine that powers the universe. Those cords are connected with our own individual polestars. A ketogenic lifestyle is one that encompasses mind, body and spirit. It is a lifestyle that demands that you link and align your personal polestar with the truth inside and around you. It takes both courage and faith, but it brings immeasurable strength and help in achieving your goals. A person out of balance with life is under stress. Chronic stress produces excessive cortisol and other powerful adrenal hormones that displace the body’s and the mind’s endocrinologic balance, leading to weight gain, weight retention, and chronic disease. This often has significant effect externally on the body in processes seen like depression, anxiety, fibromyalgia, and allowing for amplification of inflammation and auto-immune dysfunction. We refer to this inter-relationship in the medical community as psychosomatic and/or viscerosomatic dysfunction, the psyche (the mind) and/or the viscera (internal endocrine organs) directly and adversely influence the function of the soma (the structural body separate from the mind).
“He who does not know himself, does not know anything, but he who knows himself, knows the depth of all things.
” . . . If you bring forth what is within you, what you bring forth will save you. If you do not bring forth what is within you, what you do not bring forth will destroy you.” (Book of Thomas the Contender)
Point of Focus: Your life is never without meaning. Keep it real by recognizing that diet alone may not compete your answer for physical health. Having courage and faith allow you to see and embrace the truth that is right in front of you. The Alcoholics Anonymous’ 12 step program only becomes successful when one realistically and courageously applies their faith to align with the truth they have felt all along. For any long-term lifestyle change to take place, one must connect and live the principles before one truly knows they are true. In this way the Ketogenic Lifestyle becomes real.
KetoOS – Drinkable Exogenous Ketones
LIFESTYLE PRINCIPLE 3 – TO cheat, or NOT to cheat, that is the question
I have been asked this question by every patient I have placed on a ketogenic diet at least once and often three or four times throughout the course of our treatment plan. I usually answer this question with a question. “Why do you want to cheat?”
The desire to cheat usually arises form one of three reasons:
You’re not eating enough fat to satiate your appetite and you are truly hungry. The body recognizes that it can use and absorb glucose much faster than fat, as fuel, so it naturally will crave “sweets.” In this case, the case of true hunger, solution is to increase your fat intake. You should be eating at least 50% of your total calories in the form of fat.
Insulin loads are still high, stimulating rebound hunger and hedonistic cravings. You’re either eating too many carbohydrates with your diet or you’re using a sweetener that stimulates insulin without raising blood sugar (See my article The Skinny about Sweeteners).
Cheating with a specific food fulfills a psychological need, feeds an addiction or represents an obligation to fulfill a societal ritual. Journaling helps to identify and break this cycle.
If you are truly in ketosis the cravings to cheat don’t exist, they actually disappear. Other societal rituals, like birthdays, anniversaries, weddings, spiritual ceremonies or rites of passage are often tied to or use food as symbolism. In these cases, the decision to cheat is really yours.
When a person cheats, it can take as many as 3-5 days to get back into ketosis, and for some 2-3 weeks. Carbohydrate cravings will rebound and often be present for up to 72 hours after cheating. You have to decide if cheating is worth 3 days of carbohydrate cravings and 3-7 days of stifled weight loss.
Point of Focus: There are no Ketosis Police! Really. They don’t exist! Dr. Nally will not show up in uniform on your doorstep with a set of handcuffs and a bag of pork rinds. You won’t be arrested for eating bread and those of us who have been following a strict ketogenic lifestyle for years really don don’t mind at all if you decide to cheat. We will smile and we may even ask you how it tastes or if you liked the flavor, but don’t be self-conscious, because when one is in ketosis for a few months, we really don’t crave cheating any longer, and we won’t judge you. And, don’t feel obligated to justify why your cheating, this is a lifestyle. You probably won’t ask me why I chose to wear long sleeves on a hot day in Arizona, for the same reason I won’t ask you why you decided to wear a Speedo.
LIFESTYLE PRINCIPLE 4 – Hunger Management
Life comes at you pretty fast and if you’re not prepared, hunger can bite you. Most people fall off the wagon when they are unprepared for missing a meal on a stressful day. I’ve recently heard the argument that “there is no wagon, so don’t worry about falling off.” This is false security that leaves one unprepared for life events. Pioneers traveled in wagons for two reasons. First, the wagon held supplies essential for survival. Second, wagons usually traveled in wagon trains. This means that there was more than one person on the wagon and there was more than one wagon on the trail with you. Traveling with a wagon train meant you had others on the same trail with the same tools for safety and support.
In the world of fast foot, fast photos and speedy delivery, we often don’t adequately prepare for hunger or cravings. There are some essential hunger management tools for the Ketogenic Lifestyle:
Eat meals containing >50% fat. This, in and of itself, delays hunger and ensures the satiety center of the brain is happy for longer periods of time.
Carry rescue foods with you or keep them at your office or in your fridge at home. These include low-carb nuts like almonds, walnuts, macadamia nuts; Keep hard and string cheese handy for a snack. Use sliced deli-meats with the cheese as a snack when the cravings kick in. Pork Rinds, beef jerky, olives, are great natural food options.
If you have time and can cook, develop your favorite “Fat Bombs“ and have a bag full in the fridge for those cravings.
Having the moral support of a buddy, spouse, friend or work companion who checks on your progress daily, assists with meals and meal choices is priceless. Periscope, a free Twitter based App, has become a means of checking in with your Ketogenic Support group around the world that connects to those you follow on Twitter. You can follow me, @docmuscles, and a number of fascinating health Periscopes that focus on ketogenic, low-carb, whole food paleo approaches: @livinlowcarbman, @_danielleeaton, @kasandrinos, @fatissmartfuel, @domskitchen, @mikemutzel, @keribrewster, @tombilyeu, @glutenfreenj, @paleocomfort.
Being accountable to yourself in a diet journal daily and to your doctor regularly every 1-2 months also helps keep motivation going forward. Jimmy Moore, author and podcaster at the Livin’ La Vida Low-Carb Show has also posted one of the most extensive lists of physicians specializing in ketogenic diets from around the world. You can find that list here.
LIFESTYLE PRINCIPLE 5 – Stress Reduction
Pages and pages can be written about stress reduction. In fact, I’ve written about the chemical responses that stress has on weight gain in my post, Stress. . . The Weight Loss Killer. But there are a few daily essentials that should be added into the Ketogenic Lifestyle to manage stress.
First, are you getting adequate sleep? Remove the television, computer, cell phone, iPad or other electronic distraction from the bedroom. Go to bed at the same time and get up at the same time each day. Give yourself time each day away from being plugged in, logged in or on-line.
Second, over exercising or being malnourished can cause chronic stress. I have a number of patient that have been convinced that they have to work out 60 minutes a day 6-7 days per week. It is essential that you realize muscles need a minimum of 48-72 hours to recover from specific types of exercise. If you run for 60 minutes. It will take your muscles 48 hours to recover from the running. If you do upper body weight lifting, it will take 48-72 hours for those muscles to recover from that weight lifting. Exercising the same muscle group with the same exercise over stresses the muscles and leads to significant chronic stress, spiking the cortisol levels and halting weight loss and raising cholesterol & triglycerides. Under eating or fasting to starvation has the same effect.
Third, mild intensity (40% of your maximal exertion level) exercise 2-3 days a week was found in a recent study to lower cortisol and decrease over-all stress, raising serotonin and dopamine in the brain; however, moderate intensity (60% of your maximal exertion level) to high intensity (80% of your maximal exertion level) exercise was found to raise it. A simple 20 minute walk, 2-3 times per week is very effective at stress reduction, reduction in cortisol and improvement in ketosis.
Point of Focus: The goal is cortisol reduction. This can be done through regular and restful sleep and mild exercise. Chronic elevation in cortisol directly stimulates an increase in insulin by increasing the production of glucose in the body, and cortisol blockaids the thyroid axis. Both of these actions halt the ability to loose weight, amplifies the production of inflammatory hormones and drives weight gain. Cortisol also increases appetite. That’s why many people get significant food cravings when they are under stress (“stress eaters”). Cortisol also indirectly affects the other neuro-hormones of the brain including CRH (corticotrophin releasing hormone), leptin, and neuropeptide Y (NPY). High levels of NPY and CRH and reduced levels of leptin have also been shown to stimulate appetite.
Hopefully, this gives you some starting points and direction to your Ketogenic Lifestyle. If I’ve missed something that you’ve found to be essential, let me know. Its always great to hear what has helped you in your Ketogenic journey. Until next time, pass the butter!!!
It has been resoundingly clear to me over the last couple of weeks that there is a tremendous need for a principle based approach to a ketogenic diet. This approach, however, must be simple. So many of the approaches to weight loss I read about are complex and the questions that arise from these approaches are innumerable. Losing weight should not be as difficult as putting a man on the moon. To quote a patient recently, “If it ain’t simple, Doc, I ain’t doing it. . .”
I agree.
Any approach that requires the conversion of food to numbers or calories or exchanges becomes cumbersome, and I personally won’t follow it for more than a week. The principle based approach should be simple and is really based upon the mantra:
Give a man a fish and he will eat today. Teach a man to fish and he will eat for the rest of his life.
Ketogenic diets are wrongly referred to as diets. What I’m talking about is a ketogenic lifestyle. Simple lifestyle design should not be hard. So, what do you say? Shall we learn to fish?!
I assume that if you’re reading this article, you already understand that weight gain is not due to an over intake of calories. Weight gain is due to hormone signals throughout the body leading to the storage of fat . . . specifically, triglycerides being taken up into the fat cells. The hormone that independently controls uptake of fat into each fat cell is insulin. Insulin is an essential hormone, but too much of it stimulates the adipose (fat cells) to over-stock triglycerides or essentially “get fat.” It, actually, is that simple. There’s really only one rule to this lifestyle: If it raises your insulin it will halt or stall your weight loss. Write that on your hand or your forehead or in your planner, the lifestyle revolves around that one rule.
Most people start a ketogenic diet because they want to lose weight and have failed at multiple other dietary approaches. Reasons for weight control failure are often multi-faceted, but they all start with from a position of flawed understanding. The majority of approaches to weight management come from the false assumption that weight is gained because of an over-consumption of calories or a lack of physical activity to burn excess calories. People have faithfully been restricting calories and exercising to exhaustion since the early 1980’s to no avail. (Well, 1% of people succeed, but the rest of us failed this approach). The definition of insanity is repetitive completion of an ineffective action and expecting a different outcome each subsequent time around. If you still think that caloric restriction and exercise is successful, I’ll be shipping your drawstring white vest and your invitation to a padded cell shortly.
Let me put it clearly. We’ve been exercising and cutting our calories since 1975 and look at what it’s gotten us . . .
. . . . a country that is now recognized as the “United States of Corpulence.” Super-Size me has become literal. “Houston . . . we have a problem . . . !”
The rule above is based on foundational principles. Understanding of the principles allows one to successfully apply the rule above.
PRINCIPLE 1
The first principle in a ketogenic lifestyle is understanding that the problem is not caloric, but hormonal. Choices and actions from here on out must be based on this understanding. Anything that will raise insulin will thwart ketosis. Insulin stimulates lipoprotein lipase, the enzyme that pulls the triglycerides into the fat cells. Without insulin, we don’t gain weight. (That’s why type I diabetes are usually very slender and skinny).
The standard lab value for normal fasting insulin levels reflect 10-22 uIU/L as the normal. However, in my office, glucose tolerance tests and postprandial glucose tests consistent with impaired fasting glucose are routinely positive when the fasting insulin level is >5 uIU/L.
Point of Focus: If your having trouble, look at the hormones. Food stimulates hormone responses. Focus on the hormone response to your diet.
PRINCIPLE 2
A ketogenic diet is one where the body uses fatty acids as the primary fuel. Those triglycerides mentioned above are made up of three fatty acids linked to a glycerol molecule. To use the triglycerides, the three fatty acids must be broken away from the glycerol by hormone sensitive lipase (HSL). Insulin directly inhibits HSL. Keeping insulin levels low is the first step in shifting to a ketogenic metabolism. Lowering insulin allows access to the fatty acids in your fat cells. Triglycerides are not water soluble and the rate by which they can be taken up and burned in the mitochondria limits the speed by which triglycerides can be used as fuel. The by product of triglyceride burning is ketones. Ketones themselves can be used as fuel and over 4-6 weeks, the body can enhance its ability to use ketones when fat is the primary fuel. This is called “Keto-Adaptation.”
Point of Focus: Too much carbohydrate in the diet shifts the body from it’s use of fat and triglycerides back to glucose. In general, to become “keto-adapted,” limit carbohydrate to < 20 grams per day. Keep protein at around 0.8 to 1 gram of protein per pound of body weight.
KetoOS – Drinkable Exogenous Ketones
PRINCIPLE 3
Wait a minute!? Where do the ketones come in? When fatty acids are burned or oxidized in the mitochondria of cells within the liver, they are converted into Acetyl-CoA. The Acetyl-CoA is used to form ATP for energy in the Citric Acid Cycle.
IF excess Acetyl-CoA production occurs or if inadequate oxaloacetate is present, the extra Acetyl-CoA is transformed into ketone bodies – specifically beta-hydroxybutyric acid and acetoacetic acid. Fat can be oxidized or burned for fuel while ketones are being produced. Ketones are much smaller molecules and can more easily be transported in the blood than triglycerides, as they are water soluble. The ketones themselves can also be used or burned as fuel as the body upregulates the mitochondria’s ability to use the ketones as fuel as well. As I mentioned above, this process of “keto-adaptation” can take 4-6 weeks. Keto-adaptation results in humans having a greater desire to be physically active – the miraculous conversion of the couch-potato into the bacon-burning triathlete.
Point of Focus: Sugar is a drug. Its byproduct has the same hedonic effect on the brain as morphine. Sugar withdrawal can commonly cause headache, anxiousness, insomnia, dizziness, fatigue and moodiness within the first week of carbohydrate restriction on the road to keto-adaptation.
PRINCIPILE 4
For the average person to become “ketotic” or reach a state of ketosis, it takes lowering the carbohydrates to less than 20 grams per day (and sometimes less than 10 grams per day) for at least 3-7 days. Yes, it can actually take a week to reach ketosis. I have a few patient’s that are so insulin resistant that it takes longer. This means that to reach that fat burning state, one must maintain a low insulin response by restricting starch or carbohydrate intake to less than 20 grams per day for a minimum of a week. For your body to efficiently use the fuel it can take up to 6 weeks. This is why many people state that they “don’t feel good” or “can’t maintain their exercise levels” when starting a ketogenic diet. For most people, once they reach the 6 week mark, mitochondria have been unregulated and “fine tuned” to burn ketones, fat burning becomes efficient and energy levels begin to increase. In fact, for many like myself, you’ll finally feel like exercising for the first time in you life.
Point of Focus: If you’re already exercising, don’t be surprised if you feel more sluggish for the first four weeks. If you’re not exercising, I don’t recommend starting until after you pass through the Keto-Adaptive phase.
PRINCIPLE 5
Clinically, the average patient in my office will lose 5-15 lbs each month for the first three months. Then the weight loss will slow to 2-5 lbs per month. However, 1/2-1 inch continues to disappear off the waist circumference measurement every month. THIS IS NORMAL. Continued weight loss of 15 lbs a month will leave you looking like the Michelin Tire Man – rolls of skin without fat. The body slows the weight loss to keep up with skin and connective tissue remodeling. As long as ketosis is maintained, the fat will continue to melt away. At this point, I’m not so worried about scale weight as I am your waist circumference.
Point of Focus: Successful ketosis does not always affect the scale, but usually causes your pants to fall down.
PRINCIPLE 6
It has been my experience that it takes about 18 months for the average patient to reverse the insulin resistance while following a carbohydrate-restricted, high-fat ketogenic lifestyle. There is no quick fix for this. If there was, I’d be sitting on a beautiful beach in the Caribbean.
Point of Focus: The Ketogenic dietary lifestyle is actually the antidote to insulin resistance, diabetes and the diseases of civilization.
PRINCIPLE 7
Improvement in insulin resistance has also been demonstrated with mild to moderate intensity resistance exercise. Moderate intensity resistance exercise is 20-30 minutes of exercise like walking, easy jogging, cycling, lifting weights, yoga or Pilates with speeds or weight heavy enough to break a sweat, but not so fast or heavy that you cannot carry on a conversation with your exercise partner. Exercise improvesinsulin resistance – BUT IT DOESN’T CAUSE WEIGHT LOSS! Yes, I know, Jack LaLanne just rolled over in his grave. But, let me say that again. Exercise improves insulin resistance, but it does not improve weight loss!! The three largest and most intensive studies of exercise involving over 67,000 people demonstrate that you can exercise till the cows come home and you’ll average about 1% weight loss. If you exercise, realize it WILL make you hungry. Eating the wrong food (carbohydrate containing foods) will stimulate insulin release causing your exercise to be fruitless (Actually, your diet should be “fruit-less” anyway)
Point of Focus: Exercise because you feel like it, it improves insulin sensitivity and it decreases stress, not for weight loss.
PRINCIPLE 8
If you are eating enough fat, you won’t be hungry. Although this doesn’t always hold true in the case of patient’s with lepin resistance. 40-60% of patients with insulin resistance have a concomitant leptin resistance (see the article on lepin resistance here). A ketogenic diet is one in which 50% or more of total calories come from fat. No, you don’t have to count calories, just pick foods that contain 45% fat or more. Look for grass fed products as they will be higher in Omega 3 fatty acids. Red meat is 55% fat. Pork is 45% fat. This is where the chicken salad or turkey wrap fails (see Why Does Your Chicken Salad Stop Weight Loss). Look for alternatives to replace your basic meals and snacks. If you love chips, try pork rinds or make chips from fried cheese or pepperoni. Guacamole is a great replacement for bean dip.
Point of Focus: There is no need to eat 3-6 times per day. As you increase the fat in your diet you will feel more full. Eat when you are hungry, whether that is 3 times a day or once day, listen to your body.
PRINCIPLE 9
I’ve been following a ketogenic diet for over 10 years. The most common complaint I hear is, “Dr. Nally, I’m tired of eating eggs.” Ketogenic diets don’t have to be boring. There are hundreds of resources on the web for spicing up your ketogenic diet. See the Recommended Sites page above for some ideas to start. The Ketogenic Cookbook by Jimmy Moore and Maria Emmerich is a recent edition to the literature and a fantastic resource. Check out Franziska Spritzler’s Low Carb Dietitian website and new book as well. If you live in the UK, you should see Emily Maguire’s website and blog. She just completed a world tour, sampling all the low carbohydrate foods and restaurants around the world. If you are a picture person, check out the Best Keto Meals of 2015 Pinterest page followed by almost 16,000 people. If you haven’t takent the time, you should visit Dr. Andreas Eenfeldt’s website. He is one of Sweden’s premier ketogenic doctors has an immense number of resources at his website, Diet Doctor. Finding someone that can help you fine tune your diet is also essential. You can find a list of doctors that use ketogenic diets here.
Point of Focus: This lifestyle will require you to use real, whole food and cook like your grandmother or great grandmother did in the past. Unfortunately, we’ve lost a great deal of the art of cooking that needs to be re-discovered. If your lifestyle is too busy to cook and prepare real food, that busyness is probably causing you stress, another culprit in the weight gain cycle. The truth will set you free, but it will probably make you miserable first.
PRINCIPLE 10
WARNING! A very sweet patient of mine was given these instructions to treat her weight and blood sugar abnormalities. She applied these principles and they worked marvelously. She called me a few weeks later, however, mad as a wet hen. She placed her husband (not my patient at the time) on the same dietary changes. Her husband, who had significant blood pressure problems and was on four different blood pressure medications I later found out, had a sudden drop in his blood pressure and passed out. As happens to many of my patients, blood pressure, ejection fraction of the heart and blood sugars quickly begin to normalize. However, he never saw his doctor and never had is blood pressure medications adjusted. Because of the normalization that can occur in as rapidly as 1-2 weeks, the medications became much too strong, he passed out and ended up in the emergency room. These dietary principles are effective. They are often just as powerful as a number of the medications that we routinely prescribe.
Point of Focus: Please see your doctor before beginning any of these dietary recommendations, especially if you have any underlying medical conditions including Hypertension, Diabetes, Congestive Heart Failure, Coronary Artery Disease, Gout, Kidney Stones, etc., please do not try the dietary changes alone. Find a physician trained in the use of this type of dietary lifestyle in combination with close monitoring of your blood pressure, blood sugar and other key vital signs.
Stay tuned for Ketogenic Principles . . . Part II in the series where we’ll address Food Psychology, To Cheat or Not to Cheat, and Keeping it Real . . .
I have found, over time, that happiness in life seems to be the greatest when I strive for balance in the three basic aspects of life: Mind, Body & Spirit. Yes, I am a physician, and I spend the majority of my day applying advise and treatment plans that have been demonstrated to be effective through the tried and true scientific method. However, I know from personal experience, and from working closely with patients for over 15 years, that science alone, does not bring fullness and happiness to life. Truth and learning can be found through study and also by faith. Finding balance and peace physically is important, but finding that balance emotionally and spiritually are often essential. Being able to follow a Ketogenic Lifestyle effectively over the long term (longer than 6 months) actually requires understanding of some basic principles. This is the first in a series of articles regarding The Principle Based Ketogenic Lifestyle.
I treat patients with obesity, one of the most difficult diseases to address in the medical office. I find that just applying diet alone doesn’t always solve the problem. If the patient’s life is out of balance emotionally or spiritually, the stress this causes often halts effective weight loss and metabolic healing. You may disagree with me on political or religious issues, but healing is not about politics nor is it about religious doctrine – it is about understanding where we are, the path forward, and our potential to get there. The mind, body and spirit are deeply interconnected. Often, until we recognize and treat those connections, true healing cannot occur.
The first step in treating any illness, including weight, is recognition of the problem. The Medical Community has recognized Obesity as a disease, but obesity is also a symptom of underlying physical metabolic dysfunction that may be tied to the mind and spirit. Daily journaling is the tool that lets one see if the dysfunction is tied to mind or spirit. I ask my patients to keep a daily food journal. This is very important in looking at the patterns of macro-nutrient intake. But the more powerful effect of journaling allows one to see how food is tied to emotion – mentally and spiritually.
Simply writing down what you eat each day, when you eat it, and how you felt after you at it is actually quite profound. The patterns that emerge are usually seen and identified by the patient long before I ever see them. In fact, patient’s often bring those patterns up before ever showing me their food journals.
I’ve found, in keeping a food journal myself, that combining my journaling with other other daily goals, uplifting thoughts and reminders was even more helpful and powerful. This can be done on paper, a notebook, a planner or even on the computer. (I have a few patients who are accountants or engineers – they bring in complex spread sheets). What is important is daily consistency. It takes about 3-4 weeks of journaling to begin to see patterns.
I have taken the advise of one of the leaders of my church to “ponderize” a scripture, meaningful poetic verse or truth filled quote each week as part of the journaling process. He defined “ponderizing” as the act of pondering and memorizing a scripture or a favorite uplifting poem or verse each week. This is done by writing the verse on a written card or note in a place that you will see it frequently each day during the week. When you see it, read it and ponder it. Just the process of frequently reading it will lead to memorization each week. I have found that reading and pondering a verse 3-4 times a day for a week, lends itself to easy memorization. Each time you read the verse, think about it and ponder it for a moment, then go on with your day. This will give you a brief opportunity to elevate your thoughts each day, and will give you a place your mind can go and think when you don’t have to think. It gives your subconscious mind the ability to solve complex patterns at a higher level.
Said David O. McKay, “Tell me what you think about when you don’t have to think, and I’ll tell you what you are.” “As a man thinketh in his heart, so is he . . . ” (Proverbs 23:7).
For some reason, with all the cares of the day, work, family and the challenges of life, I have fallen out of this habit for some time. When this leader mentioned this process in his comments, I was reminded of the peace and balance I used to feel each week when doing this simple activity. I have recommitted myself to restart this activity and I invite you to do the same. This time to ponder opens your mind and allows you access the deeper worries and fears holding you from what you what to accomplish. It takes great courage to make permanent lifestyle and dietary changes. When someone can’t clearly see what lies ahead, it fills them with fear, doubt or both. But journaling, even in its simplest form, gives a person the ability to resist and then master the patterns that have kept them from change. As Mark Twain said, “Courage is resistance to fear, mastery of fear – not absence of fear.”
Courage is tested when we purse difficult goals, fight against disease with unknown outcomes, or work to regain health. The testing can be painful. Journaling, and ponderizing in the process, gives courage to take small steps, one day at a time. Admitting to, journaling when we fail or make mistakes, fear of failure or feeling unsure actually increases our courage. Being given a week to ponderize an uplifting scripture or verse enhances that courage . Journaling successes and failures empowers us individually. The psychiatrist Carl Jung wrote:
“There appears to be a conscience in mankind which severely punishes the man who does not somehow and at some time, at whatever cost to his pride, cease to defend and assert himself, and instead confess himself fallible and human. Until he can do this, an impenetrable wall shuts him out from the living experience of felling himself a man among men. Here we find a key to the great significance of true unstereotyped confession – a significance known in all the initiation and mystery cults of the ancient world, as is shown by a saying from the Greek mysteries: ‘Give up what thou hast, and thou will receive.'”
Journaling and ponderizing allows one a form of confession and renewal. It gives one courage that you have survived today’s challenges and seen the pattern of fallibility in them. It is actually energizing. And, the path to healing begins to become clear.
Journaling also is a great way to outline side effects from carbohydrate withdrawl that will last for 2-4 weeks (That’s for another blog post, however).
Feel free to ask me about the verse that I am ponderizing each week. I will happily tell you which verse I am pondering and memorizing; but, I will in tern, ask you which verse you are ponderizing.
This week, the verse I am ponderizing comes from the Bible – Genesis 35:2-3:
“Then Jacob said unto his household, and to all that were with him, Put away the strange gods that are among you, and be clean, and change your garments: And let us arise, and go up to Beth-el; and I will make there an altar unto God, who answered me in the day of my distress, and was with me in the way which I went.”
Did you begin your food journal? And, what verse are you going to ponderize this week?
as well as the fat that is found in our food is found in the form of triglycerides. Each triglyceride molecule is made of a “glyceride” (glycerol backbone) and three fatty acids (hence the “tri”) that look like tails. Some of the fat in our adipose cells come from the food we eat, but interestingly, the rest comes from carbohydrates
before they can be taken up into the fat cells. The reconstitution of the fatty acids with glycerol is called esterification. Interestingly, the process of lipolysis and esterification is going on continuously, and a ceaseless stream of free fatty acids are flowing in and out of the fat cells. However, the flow of fatty acids in and out of the fat cells depends upon the level of glucose and insulin available. As glucose is burned for fuel (oxidized) in the liver or the fat cell, it produces glycerol phosphate. Glycerol phosphate provides the molecule necessary to bind the glycerol back to the free fatty acids. As carbohydrates are being used as fuel, it stimulates increased triglyceride formation both in the fat cell and in the liver, and the insulin produced by the pancreas stimulates the lipoprotein lipase molecule to increased uptake of the fatty acids into the fat cells (3).
That something else should be fat. Protein must be moderated, as it will also be stored as fat if you eat too much. So, if the carbohydrates are kept low, fat intake can be increased and the body will pick the fat it wants and essentially throw the rest out without raising cholesterol, causing weight gain or causing heart disease. This is why we want you to use good natural animal fats like butter, hard cheese, olive oil, coconut oil, avocado, etc. Look for fats highest in omega-3 fatty acids as these decrease inflammation and improved weight loss. Look for meats highest in fat like red meat (55% fat) and pork (45% fat). Take the food pyramid and flip it over.
20% of women that I see in my practice who are over 55 years old, need some degree of estrogen replacement before they are able to lose weight. Estrogen plays a very large role in regulation of the metabolism and when deficient, causes weight retention or weight gain. Talk to your doctor about the risks and benefits of estrogen for you individually in this situation.
