Look what I just got in the mail this afternoon. . . my copy of Jimmy Moore & Maria Emmerich’s The Ketogenic Cookbook!
Wow. Great info, fantastic recipes (with amazing pictures, by the way!) and the most up to date ketogenic advise out there. I’m impressed.
What a fantastic addition to my library. I was going snap a few shots of my favorite dishes in it, but my wife picked it up while I was typing and won’t put it down. . . .
A recent study, published in JAMA Surgery, this week compares the three-year outcomes of bariatric surgery versus lifestyle intervention for type II diabetics. This particular study made the headlines of the Wall Street Journal because the outcomes revealed “Weight-Loss Surgery Better Than Diet and Exercise in Treating Type 2 Diabetes…”
Really?! That is news to me, a baratrician that’s been treating type II diabetes for over 15 years! This simple three year study in 62 patient contradicts what I’ve seen in my office for 15 years. This study and the media-hype associated with it are a serious problem. Why? Because the study was based on a flawed design.
We all know that baratric surgery has significant weight loss as a result. And, we all know that most of those patients with diabetes have significant improvement in their diabetes at the 2-5 year mark (what happens after 5 years is a completely different story). But why compare that to a poorly designed lifestyle protocol that failed to show successful weight loss? Yes, poorly designed.
This study was based on protocols from the Diabetes Prevention Program and the Look AHEAD trial, both of which were very large trials restricting calories, fat and increasing exercise. Both of these trials failed to show any significant weight loss and failed to produce any significant reduction in overall mortality. Why? Because both trials used the wrong dietary approach. We’ve know for years, as was emphasized by the Women’s Health Initiative study as well, that caloric restriction combined with exercise doesn’t reduce body weight in the long run by more than 1%. So the bariatric surgeons in the study above compare a known effective treatment to a known ineffective treatment? And, it gets Wall Street Journal Headlines. It’s a sad day for medicine. And an even sadder day for the treatment of obesity.
Is no one listening? Weight loss is not a question of thermodynamics – it is not the calorie in / calorie out dogma we’ve been brainwashed into believing over the last 50 years. Weight loss is hormonal. The study published in JAMA Surgery this week proves that. Baratric surgery effects grelin and the forced dietary changes reduce insulin (patients receive what equates to a low carbohydrate diet post bypass surgery). Both of which have significant effect on weight gain and loss. Caloric restriction and exercise affect neither of these.
Carbohydrate restriction, on the other hand affects insulin dramatically. Carbohydrate restriction turns off the tremendous excess insulin hormonal response that occurs in up to 85% of the patient’s I see in my office. Call me when the bariatric surgeons actually compare bariatric surgery to a true ketogenic diet.
I’ve personally been following and prescribing ketogenic diets to my patients since 2005. When I started on my ketogenic journey, it was called a “Low Carbohydrate Diet.” Over the last 5-10 years, we’ve learned a thing or two about how the body processes carbohydrate, protein and fat. Specifically, it’s not just the restriction of the carbohydrates that leads to metabolic health, but appropriate protein intake and significant emphasis on the level and type of fat intake as well. The majority of people who cut out carbohydrates will initially see successful weight loss, but to maintain that weight loss and see significant metabolic changes that reverse the diseases of civilization, an understanding of protein and fat needs are essential.
It’s Not Necessarily a High Protein Diet
Most people, when they hear you’re following a “Low-Carb” diet . . . respond with, “Oh, you are on that high protein, Adkins’ thing, . . . right?!”
Well, not really. A true ketogenic diet is NOT a “high protein diet.” However, you must be ingesting enough protein to maintain muscle, hair growth and energy levels. Most people, having been brainwashed in grade school and middle school about the horrors of fat in the diet, assume that if you’re not eating carbohydrates, then you must be eating extra protein to stay satiated. (No one would ever intentionally increase the fat in their diet, right?!!) However, remember that protein and fat usually come together in the sources that the Good Lord put them in.
That’s the impression that most people in my office get when I mention the words “Low-Carb” or “Adkins.” And, before I have a chance to explain that I’m not recommending that you race home to eat three large turkey legs and a pound of turkey bacon, the vegetarians gather their things to leave and the former home economics teachers begin to get chest pain at the mental picture in their heads.
How Are Ketones Made?
A ketogenic diet is one which allows your body to use ketones as it’s primary fuel source. Ketones are produced from the breakdown of triglyceride and free fatty acids. Ketones are essentially produced by two distinctly different events:
1) Starvation caused by prolonged periods without food (which is essentially what happens to type I diabetics when they have no insulin at all in their systems)
2) When fat is ingested as the primary fuel, and very low levels of insulin are concurrently produced, primarily when the diet has minimal to no carbohydrate present (allowing the body to activate its free fatty acid reserves found within in the adipose cells).
The body is an amazing machine. It was designed to take any of the three main macro-nutrients (carbohydrate, protein or fat) as fuel and function quite well. It’s like a futuristic car that can run on unleaded gasoline, oil, or diesel fuel. It is able to recognize which fuel is present and run quite well off of any of the three. The amazing thing about the body is that we mix up all three fuel types and just pour them into the tank. Impressively, the body can separate them out and run very well in the short term on any combination of mixes. We don’t have cars or trucks that do that today . . . maybe in the future . . .?
We have Two Fuel Systems
I like to equate carbohydrates to unleaded fuel. These are clean burning, easy to access and cheap. However, the body requires the production of insulin to use this “unleaded” type of fuel. When carbohydrates are identified to be present in the liver and pancreas, insulin is released so that the rest of the cells throughout the body can “open the tank” and let the carbohydrate into the cell to be used as fuel. The challenge is that carbohydrates don’t store very well in the form they are supplied in, so, as a protective mechanism against starvation and famine, if excess carbohydrate is found in the system, it is converted into triglyceride. Insulin is required for this. Interestingly, when your insulin levels rise, the signal to the body is that “unleaded fuel” is in the system, so it stores any fats and excess carbohydrates in the form of free fatty acid and triglyceride. Carbohydrate stimulate an insulin response and cause fat storage. It is the same reason we give corn to cattle — to plump them up before taking them to market.
Fat then is the “diesel fuel” of macro-nutrients. It burns well, can be stored very easily, and provides over twice the energy to the body when measured in the form of k-cal per gram. Fat is used preferentially when there is limited or no insulin floating around the blood stream and is quickly and efficiency stored when other forms of fuel are available. (Insulin being the key hormone signaling that other fuel is around.)
Nutritional Ketosis is Using Fat as Your Optimum Fuel
So what is this “ketosis thing?” It is a method of dietary change (a lifestyle) that intentionally focuses the body’s metabolism to use fat (in the form of triglyceride & free fatty acid) as its primary fuel. Leading to weight loss, dramatically improved blood sugars, significantly improved cholesterol and triglyceride levels, and notably improved inflammatory markers.
“But don’t you end up eating a lot more protein on your weight loss program?” I frequently get asked.
Honestly, No.
Protein and fat are both very filling, and most people find that limiting the carbohydrates actually causes less hunger and diminishes the rebound carbohydrate cravings often stimulated by the two or three slices of bread, pasta or that potato often occurring 2-3 hours later. Interestingly, most people don’t eat that much more and the protein levels remain fairly constant. Because fat and protein come together in meats, eggs, fish, etc., satiation occurs with just minor increases in dietary intake real animal food. I don’t recommend increase the fat alone. I recommend increasing the amount of real animal protein until you are full. This is even more satiating and many people find themselves eating only twice a day when they are hungry.
Excessive protein in those who are morbidly obese with severe overproduction of insulin can experience a spike the insulin levels further with large amounts of protein. Protein can be equated to the oil you put in your car. Protein is a building block used for muscle, connective tissue and some essential metabolic functions. When too much protein, in this group is ingested, it spikes the insulin. (See my article on Why Your Chicken Salad is Making you Fat)
Most people have problems when they start supplementing with protein shakes. These often contain sweeteners that raise insulin and consequently halts your weight loss – or even causing weight gain.
Consider yourself warned . . . ! What follows is “Low-Carb Food PORN.” I’m not completely sure if it is just that these are catching my eye, or if my favorite Low-Carb recipe goddesses are just posting from the recipe snack bar today, but WOW! Here is a second post today about a wonderful low-carb, high fat snack. Thank you Carolyn Ketchum. This one has a little more carbohydrate in it ~ 6g per serving, so you have be a bit cautious on how many you consume but, just look . . .
Carolyn posted the recipe here at www.AllDayIDreamAboutFood.com. Thanks, Carolyn! I can’t wait to try these.
Found this info-graphic while surfing Banner Health’s information pages. Many of my patients get a very confused look on their face when I ask them to restrict carbohydrates. Sugar is the most prevalent form of carbohydrate in the Standard American Diet or SAD diet. Sugar comes by more than one name. This info-graphic is actually very helpful. All of these names are synonymous with weight gain and cholesterol formation.
I recently read a blog post decrying anyone that would recommend a low carbohydrate / ketogenic diet to their patients.
What?!
In fact, this particular blog outlined a number of “adverse reactions” to a ketogenic diet, and based upon these perceived reactions, the writer advised severe caution with its use in just about anyone. It is important to note at the outset that most of the data this blogger quotes are from older studies completed in children for the treatment of epilepsy with specific liquid ketogenic dietary meal replacements. (Not what you’d expect in a low-carb / ketogenic diet for the average obese adult today.)
Thanks to recent misinformation by a number of medical professionals, including the person writing the blog referenced above, a poor understanding of fatty acid metabolism by the general community, and a distinct lack of understanding of human adaptability recorded over the last 5,000-6,000 years, there is still significant confusion about ketogenic diets.
It is important to recognize the crucial fact that the human body is designed to function quite well when supplied any of three macronutrients: carbohydrates, proteins or fats. It does so through an amazing series of enzymatic reactions referred to as the Krebs (tricarboxylic acid) cycle, producing needed ATP (adenosine triphosphate) required for our muscles to contract, our heart to beat and our diaphragm to expand our lungs. What’s even more amazing that that the body was designed to recognize the season we are in based up on the food we eat. That is, until we invented refrigerators in 1913. (Now our bodies think it’s year round summer time . . . wait . . . I live in Arizona where it is year round summer time.)
No, this is not a post about unplugging your refrigerator, living on solar, getting off the grid and saving energy.
Our bodies recognize the seasons we are in based upon inherent hormone release. The key hormone is insulin. Insulin can be looked at as the seasonal indicator to our bodies. Insulin production rises and falls based on our intake of carbohydrates (sugar, starches, some fibers). Insulin, essentially, tells our bodies when it is a “time of plenty” and when it was a “time of famine.” Why? You ask. We didn’t have refrigerators 100 years ago and you were lucky if you had a root cellar. The body needs to know when to store for the famine (the winter) that was around the corner. Insulin is that signal.
During the summer, potatoes, carrots, corn and other fruits are readily available. These are all starchy carbohydrates and they all require the body to stimulate an insulin response so that they can be absorbed. Insulin stimulates fat storage (J Clin Invest. 2000;106(4):473-481. doi:10.1172/JCI10842). Just like bears, our bodies were designed to store for the winter.
If you think back in history, your grandparents probably used stored meats & cheeses that could be salted or smoked for preserving during this time of year. Those crossing the plains were commonly found with pemmican, a concentration of fat and protein used as a portable nutrition source in the absence of other food. (Chapter VIII. Narrative of the Life of David Crockett, of The State of Tennessee, Written by Himself, Sixth Edition [E.L. Carey and A. Hart:Philadelphia] 1834, 1837; Marcy, The Prairie Traveler, p. 31.) Think about conversations you may have had with your grandmother when she told you that for Christmas, she received an orange. A single orange for a gift?! Many of my patients drink 12-15 of them in a glass every morning. The winter diets of our grandparents were very low in starches and carbohydrates. When carbohydrate intake is low, little insulin is produced.
Again, insulin is the hormone that tells you that you’re in “a time of plenty” and stimulates weight gain and cholesterol production to prepare for winter. Those prescribing the use of ketogenic diets understand this innate human adaptive trait, and use it to effect changes in weight, cholesterol and other desired metabolic changes.
Now, let’s define the difference between ketosis and keto-acidosis and try to clarify the misinformation that is being spread around the blogosphere.
A ketone is a molecule the body produces from the breakdown of fat and some proteins (amino acids). There are specifically three types of ketones: beta-hydroxybutyric acid, acetoacetic acid and acetone. If ketosis was “bad,” then why would our bodies produce these molecules? They are not bad, and in fact, multiple studies show that the body is often more efficient and effective when it functions on ketones rather than glucose as its primary fuel source. The body can only supply a limited amount of sugar or glucose for fuel. If you talk to runners, marathoners or triathletes, they will tell you that after about 45-90 minutes of continuous endurance exercise the glucose supply runs out and they will experience what is termed a “bonk” (have a low-blood sugar or hypoglycemic episode). Unfortunately, our bodies can only store about 18-24 hours of glucose.
However, the body can store days upon days of fat in the form of triglyceride in the fat cells. Triglyceride is broken down into ketones. If glucose is the “unleaded” fuel, you can think of ketones as the “diesel fuel” that is easier to store and runs longer.
The average body functioning on ketones as the primary fuel will have a ketone level measured in the blood somewhere between 0.4 and 4 mmol/L. Because of a balance that is created by the use of ketones and a feedback mechanism that kicks in when the ketone level rises, the body will maintain a pH of around 7.4.
Ketoacidosis is dramatically different. If you are a type I diabetic, you don’t produce any insulin. The feedback mechanism regulating ketone use is broken and the ketone levels and triglyceride breakdown speeds up because the body can’t access glucose and can’t produce insulin. The ketone levels spike and the level can rise to > 25 mmol/L. In the presence of a high blood sugar and high ketone level, the acid level in the blood shifts to a pH of less than 7.3. This is referred to as metabolic acidosis and can be life threatening as the low pH shuts down the bodies’ enzymatic processes and a person becomes critically ill and without treatment, can die. (Kitabchi AE et al., Clinical features and diagnosis of diabetic ketoacidosis and hyperosmolar hyperglycemic state in adults. www.uptodate.com, May 2015.)
If you’re not a type I diabetic, you have nothing to worry about. Regardless of what the “ketogenic nay-sayers” blog about, your liver makes approximately 240g of glucose per day, this stimulates a basal release of insulin which keeps the pH in check. It’s also what keeps weight loss at a consistent pace of around 2-10 lbs per month.
If you are a type I diabetic, don’t fret. Carbohydrate restriction can still be used very effectively. It just takes some balancing and understanding of your individual metabolism. Talk to your physician and/or medical bariatrician about how to follow a carbohydrate restricted diet while using insulin.
What about all the other “adverse effects” the blogosphere and other so-called experts claim about ketogenic diets?
Let’s take them on one by one. Are you ready?
Gastrointestinal (GI) disturbances – Yes. Any time you change your diet you may experience diarrhea, constipation or gassiness. Most of the time, this is because you are either 1) not eating enough leafy greens (fiber) or 2) you’re using a supplement that contains an artificial sweetener. Most of the studies on ketogenic diets did not incorporate fiber and the studies used to make this point were on children who used a ketogenic fat supplement shake or liquid preparations containing these artificial sweeteners to make them palatable. If you have spoken to any bariatrician, they will tell you, the best way to follow a ketogenic diet is to eat real food. If you want to read about the anecdotal GI effects of sweeteners, read the comment section in Amazon about the Haribo Sugar Free Gummy Bears.
Inflammation Risk – In every patient that I have placed on a ketogenic diet in the last 8 years, all inflammatory markers including CRP, Sedimentation Rate and Uric Acid have all decreased. Inflammation gets better on an appropriately formulated ketogenic diet. The older studies of ketogenic diets in children contain most of their fat from Omega-6 fatty acids from vegetable oil which will increase inflammation and oxidative stress, spike the cortisol levels and have the secondary effect of actually raising the triglycerides. (Simopoulos AP,The importance of the ratio of omega-6/omega-3 essential fatty acids, Biomed Pharmacother., 2002 Oct;56(8):365-79.)
Muscle Cramps/Weakness – The process of weight loss occurs by burning fat into CO2 and water. We breathe the CO2 out, but the water produced has to follow salts out through the kidneys. Hence, we lose salts. This can cause weakness and muscle cramps. The solution? Stop restricting salt on a low carbohydrate diet. We are the only mammal that restricts salt and we do it because low-fat diets cause us to retain water. Low carbohydrate diets do the opposite. Use sea salt or sip beef or chicken bouillon broth with your dinner. The use of yellow mustard also helps (the small amount of quinine in yellow mustard stops the cramping). If you have congestive heart failure, talk to your doctor about monitoring your salt intake in balance with your diuretic or water pill.
Hypoglycemia – If you read the ketogenic diet research, most of it was done on epileptic children. The diets called for a period of starvation, then the use of a ketogenic liquid based on the John’s Hopkin’s protocol. It is a well-known fact in medicine that starvation in children can frequently cause hypoglycemia, especially in children with other genetic or congenital defects leading to forms of epilepsy. In clinical practice, with ketogenic diet use in adults, hypoglycemia is rare.
Low Platelet Count (Thrombocytopenia) – Again, this was seen in the epileptic children who were placed into starvation first, then introduced a liquid fat replacement shake to stop intractable seizures. These liquids or shakes were often nutrient deficient in other essentials. Folic acid, B12 and copper deficiency can occur when not eating “real food.” Low platelet counts are rarely seen on ketogenic diets based around “real food.” Many children in the ketogenic studies had been on or were concomitantly on valproic acid for their seizures. Valproic acid is commonly known to cause thrombocytopenia (Barry-Kravis E et al, Bruising and the ketogenic diet: evidence for diet-induced changes in platelet function. Ann Neurol. 2001 Jan;49(1):98-103.; Kraut E, Easy Bruising, http://www.uptodate.com, May 2015.)
Easy Bruising – This is usually due to inadequate protein supplementation as was the case in much of the ketogenic literature where protein levels were also restricted. (Kraut E, Easy Bruising, http://www.uptodate.com, May 2015.)
Pancreatitis – Patients who are insulin resistant or have impaired fasting glucose commonly have high triglycerides. Elevation in triglycerides itself is a cause of pancreatitis. Ketogenic diets lower the triglycerides. However, if a patient has not been following their diet as directed, spikes in the triglycerides can occur placing the person at risk for pancreatitis.
Long QT Intervals/Heart Arrhythmias – The list of things causing Long QT intervals and abnormal heart rhythms is long and variable (Acquired Long QT Syndrome. Berul C et al. www.uptodate.com, May 2015). It is well know that starvation, rapid weight loss and liquid protein diets can cause a delay in the conduction signal in the heart. Anyone wishing to start any diet should have an electrocardiogram (EKG) through their doctor to ensure that the diet (of any type) doesn’t exacerbate a prolonged QT interval.
Cardiomyopathy – Prolonged QT intervals have been associated with cardiomyopathy and the former can stimulate the later. Any diet that has the potential to prolong a QT interval has the potential to cause cardiomyopathy. Hence the need for regular EKG monitoring on any diet (Acquired Long QT Syndrome. Berul C et al. www.uptodate.com, May 2015).
Lipid/Cholesterol Changes – In the 8 years I have been applying ketogenic diets to patients, I have seen dramatic improvement in the triglycerides and HDL levels. The only time triglycerides rise over 100 is if the patient is using artificial sweeteners or is cheating on the carbohydrate restriction. Total cholesterol commonly rises, however, this is indicative of the fact that there is a shift in the LDL particle size and this affects the calculation of both total cholesterol and LDL-C. In light of this, most of my patients have dramatic improvement in triglycerides and small dense LDL particle number. I’ve included the common cholesterol changes I seen in my office as a few case reports to demonstrate the effectiveness of a ketogenic diet:
Myocardial Infarction – It is interesting that one blogger includes this on the list of adverse reactions, however, when you actually read the study, the author of the paper make an “assumption” that there was potential for heart attack due to an elevated total cholesterol, however, a correlation was never made. Again, in the 8 years I have been using ketogenic diets, I have seen dramatic improvement in cholesterol profiles, inflammatory markers, atherosclerosis and carotid intimal studies (Shai I et al, Circulation 2010; 121:1200-1208).
Menstrual Irregularities / Amenorrhea – It is well known that any diet causing protein or other nutritional deficiency will affect the menstrual cycle first and growth second. The only time menstrual irregularities occur with a ketogenic or Low-Carb diet is when a patient is not taking in enough protein or is not eating real food. What amazes me is that a properly applied ketogenic diet causes normalization of the menstrual cycle, and in my practice, I’ve had a number of women successfully be able to conceive after making a ketogenic dietary change.
For more details on the nutrient content of a ketogenic diet, see the recent article by a friend of mine, Maria Emmerich. She’s been creating ketogenic diets for years and has a number of fantastic books my wife and I have been using in our home over the last nine years. She is one among many that can give you some direction on how to devise a healthy, real food based ketogenic diet. See the page on my website here that will give you some direction in formulating your Ketogenic Lifestyle.
So, to celebrate Mother’s Day, today, with my family, I am going to indulge in some Low-Carb / Ketogenic Cheese Cake!! Happy Mother’s Day, to all of you and especially to all you mothers out there making a healthy difference in the lives of your families! (You can find the recipe for this delicious cheese cake here)
In the words of Sir William Ostler, “If it were not for the great variability among individuals, medicine might well be a science and not an art.”
We just got a sample pack of Lily’s Chocolate. This is a Stevia and erythritol sweetened chocolate that has no aftertaste and doesn’t cause the stomach upset that many experience with chicory root based products. I am always looking for good low carbohydrate alternatives for snacks, as rescue foods, or to assist in baking.
My wife found this chocolate in a recipe that Carolyn Ketchum had posted on her website, All Day I Dream About Food. It is quite tastey!! Thanks, Caroyln!! (By the way, I dream about food all day long, too.)
I scanned a copy of the wrapper for the Salted Almond & Milk Flavor. I have to admit, I ate half the bar. It was that good!!
For those looking for an alternative chocolate for a snack or to use in a recipe, this may be the answer. You can find their whole line of chocolates here.
Have you noticed that there are a large number of advertisements in the media about checking your testosterone or “Low T” Syndrome? It seems like this is the new advertising trend on the radio and late night TV.
Suddenly, everyone’s testosterone is low and men are complaining about their libido, . . . or are they?
If you practice medicine long enough, you’ll see a trend that seems to have arisen as our waistlines have expanded. About half of the men in my office with insulin resistance, pre-diabetes or diabetes have low testosterone levels. But this shouldn’t be a surprise. Type II diabetes, metabolic syndrome and insulin resistance are all driven by an over production in insulin in response to a carbohydrate load in the meal. Patients with these conditions produce between two to ten times the normal insulin in response to a starchy meal. A number of studies both in animal and human models demonstrate that insulin has a direct correlation on testosterone suppression in the blood. This has been demonstrated in both men and women. In fact, glucose intake has been shown to suppress testosterone and LH in healthy men by suppressing the gonadal hormone axis and more predominant testosterone suppression is seen in patient with insulin resistance or metabolic syndrome.
In fact, to put it simply, insulin increases the conversion (aromitization) of testosterone to estrogen in men (it does the opposite in women). Interestingly, Leptin resistance has a similar effect. I tend to see the worst lowering of testosterone in men with both insulin and leptin resistance.
How to you improve your testosterone? Supplemental testosterone has been shown to help, but it comes with some risks, including prostate enlargement and stimulating growth of prostate cancer. The most natural way to improve your testosterone is to change your diet.
A low carbohydrate or ketogenic diet turns down the insulin production and allows the testosterone to be available for use by the body. A ketogenic diet has the effect of reducing leptin resistance as well through weight loss. A simple dietary change of this type is frequently seen in my office to increase testosterone by 100-150 points.
What is a ketogenic diet? It is a diet that restricts carbohydrates to less than 50 grams per day, thereby causing the body to use ketones as the primary fuel source. So, for breakfast tomorrow morning, hold the oatmeal (1/2 cup of Quaker Instant Oatmeal is 31 grams of carbohydrates) and have the bacon and eggs. And, rather than have the cheesecake for desert this evening, have an extra slice of steak butter on your rib-eye and hold the potato.
I have multiple patients that come to my office that we follow and treat for weight loss and metabolic syndrome. They are discouraged that their weight loss has stopped or is very, very slow. The most frequent problem I find when they bring in their food journals is the “healthy chicken salad.”
“What?! But, Doc, Chicken Salad is healthy?! RIGHT?”
The chicken salad shows up on their journal almost daily. Somehow, we’ve been indoctrinated that the chicken salad is good for us. I want you to look closely at the image that was recently shared on the internet below. How is the nutrient value of your chicken salad any different than the Big Mac?
Why is this unhealthy? The carbohydrate content greater than 20-30 grams will cause a spike in insulin. When insulin spikes, the body is told to store fat (and it will store fat for up to 12 hours) . . . Yes, the 24 grams of fat in the salad now become dangerous in the presence of an insulin spike. In my patients with metabolic syndrome, they will produce between two and ten times the insulin and store two to ten times the fat. (Ten Big Macs would have tasted better . . . )
There is actually more carbohydrate in your salad than in the big mac. Why not add a strawberry shake just to finish putting the nail in the coffin? And we wonder why we are having trouble with weight loss?
The other issue, and probably of even greater importance, is that chicken breast has the second highest content of lysine & argenine (two of the 10 essential amino acids) count of all the poultry family. This is second only to turkey breast, which also contains a large amount of tryptophan (a third essential amino acid that spikes insulin). Why is this a problem? Because argenine, tryptophan and lysine all stimulate an insulin response on their own, separate from glucose. We need these amino acids, however, when our meals contain a predominance of these amino acids, it rasies insulin significantly in those who are insulin resistant (pre-diabetic).
Those 43 carbohydrates, plus the stimulus from a meat high in argenine, lysine and tryptophan, spike your insulin, kick you out of nutritional ketosis and slow weight loss for up to 48 hours.
Please, if you are following a low-carb or ketogenic diet, get rid of the chicken salad.
A number of patients come in to the office struggling with loosing weight. When I review their dietary journals with them, I notice that many of them never stop eating fruit (because, fruit is good for you, right?!). Well, lets put it this way:
One banana for breakfast is equal to . . .
. . . just over seven (7) teaspoons of sugar.
Count them . . . seven (7) teaspoons.
If your eating a banana for breakfast, it is halting your weight loss for up to 12 hours. Give the banana’s to the monkeys and cook up some sausage and eggs for breakfast tomorrow.
A friend posted this image and I couldn’t help but think about this little cartoon throughout the day. In the 15 years that I have been in medical practice, it was re-emphasized to me that my definition of cure and the patient’s definition of cure may at times be notably different or even in opposition.
I am reminded of a sweet a patient in her early nineties that was brought in by her three well meaning and very caring daughters. This patient was a type II diabetic and, for the most part, her blood sugar was in pretty good control. To put it in medical terms, her morning blood sugars were in the 120 range and her Hemoglobin A1c (HbA1c) was a 6.4%. She was obese by the standards of her body mass index (BMI) and her cholesterol was elevated.
The concern of her three daughters, “there to rat her out,” as the patient put it, was that she was eating donuts for breakfast each morning for the last few months. I noted that her HbA1c had gone up from 5.9% at the last visit. We discussed the fact that the change in her dietary intake appeared to have caused the rise in her blood sugar and her cholesterol.
With my affirmation of the cause as ammunition, the patient’s daughters began to individually take shots at her choice of meals over the last year. They did it, I could see because they loved and cared for heir mother. But I noticed the patient’s demeanor change suddenly, and a bit of trust between me and my patient began to slip.
This sweet centenarian turned and looked at me, square in the eye, and then proceeded to give me an education.
“Dr. Nally, do you know how old I am?” she asked.
“Why, yes, you are 93 years old,” I replied.
“And do you know how much longer I am going to be alive on this earth?” she inquired.
“Well, no. I do not know how much longer you will be alive, but I can tell you that you have out lived most of your peers and the average age of most Americans.”
“Then, why the hell are you, and my daughters, worried about me eating a damn do-nut?” she yelled. “My blood sugar is still pretty good and I figure that if I have to be around on this earth any longer, then by stars, I am going to enjoy my favorite breakfast. If it kills me, then so be it. I am going to enjoy it.”
Well, that was that. The cure was to enjoy her last few years upon this earth.
BuzzFeed’s Christine Byrne has a great article on 31 ideas for Low-Carb breakfasts . . . I’m going to have to try some of these. The “Eggs in a Cloud” looks fantastic . . .
There are a number of recipes for “Fat Bombs” on the internet, but this one is my wife’s version. These have been a lifesaver for starting and maintaining a Low-Carbohydrate or Ketogenic diet over the last few years. They are fantastic mid-meal or anytime Low-Carb snacks, full of satiating fat, that really help during the holidays. I mentioned Fat Bombs to my patients in my Low-Carb Group Visit Class today and I promised to post them here:
Fat Bombs:
1 stick of real Butter softened
1 cup Coconut Oil
1/2-2/3 cup Erythritol
1 tsp liquid Stevia
1/3 cup Cocoa Powder
1 cup Peanut Butter or Almond Butter
2 cups chopped Macadamia Nuts or slivered Almonds
1-2 cups of Coconut
Mix together and place 1-2 table spoon sized scoops in small muffin tin or on wax paper. Must be kept refrigerated to remain firm.
Many of you have already seen my article about sweeteners, which ones work well and which ones make you fat. If not click here for the article. Stevia is one of those sweeteners that doesn’t spike your insulin as long as it isn’t crystallized with dextrose or maltodextrin. I actually found the stevia plant at one of my nearby nurseries, thanks Moon Valley Nursery.
Hypertension (elevated blood pressure) is one of the triad symptoms of metabolic syndrome. I see this to some degree a very large majority of the people seen in my office. Many people are so used to having borderline or elevated blood pressure, and not successfully controlling it through caloric restriction, they are told it is a “genetic problem,” placed on blood pressure medication and sent on their way. The problem is that most of these people will have a progressive elevation in blood pressure over time and these medications are continually raised until the person is on four or five different blood pressure medications at maximal doses. Again, their genetics are blamed and that is the end of it. Or is it?!
When I first started treating the insulin resistance problem in the human, rather than the blood pressure problem, I began to see immediate reductions in blood pressure within one to two weeks. So much of a reduction that if I didn’t warn the patient that they should begin to back down their medications, they would experience symptoms of dizziness, light-headedness, headache and a few patient’s nearly passing out. I often wondered why applying a ketogenic diet had such a profound effect on blood pressure so quickly. Dr. Robert Lustig helped answer that question for me.
In order to understand how the Standard American Diet (we call it the SAD diet in my office) raises your blood pressure, it is important to understand how the body processes the basic sugar molecule. Sugar is one glucose molecule bound to a fructose molecule. This is broken down in the body and 20% of the glucose is metabolized in the liver, the other 80% is sent on to be used as fuel throughout the body. Fructose, however, is where the problems arise. 100% of the fructose is metabolized in the liver, and the by product of fructose metabolism is increasing the liver’s production of MORE glucose and the byproduct of uric acid. Uric acid is produced and this inhibits the production of nitric oxide. The diminished nitric oxide in the presence of an increased level of glucose (stimulating increased insulin production) constricts the blood vessels and raises blood pressure. Yes, that donut you just ate raised your blood pressure for the next 12 hours.
So, how do you lower your blood pressure through diet? First, cut out all the simple sugars. These include anything with table sugar, high fructose corn syrup and corn syrup.
Second, limit your overall intake of other sources of carbohydrates including any type of bread, rice, pasta, tortilla, potato, corn and carrots. Realize that fruit is fructose, and when taken with other forms of glucose can have the same effect as table sugar.
Third, if you are taking blood pressure medications, see your doctor about close monitoring of your blood pressure as it can drop within 1-2 weeks of making these dietary changes.
A few of my patients have come in struggling with their weight this week, following what they assumed to be a low carbohydrate diet. They were eating yogurt for breakfast, a chicken salad for lunch, and chicken and vegetables for dinner. A true low carbohydrate diet is ketogenic (it derives fuel from ketones) and is the byproduct of fatty acid metabolism. That means your fuel is coming from fat, not protein or carbohydrate. The presence of glucose, fructose, lactose or other sugars (or many sugar alcohols) shut fatty acid metabolism down and halt the process of weight loss and frequently increase weight gain. Too much protein does the same thing. A chicken salad is not ketogenic. It may be low carb, but without adequate fat, the absence of glucose drives the body to use protein as it’s primary fuel source. It is essential to maintain ketosis that a low carbohydrate diet moderate the protein and increase the fats to upwards of 60-70% of the total caloric intake.
Bacon is a 50/50 food. (I’m not talking about turkey bacon . . . that’s not real bacon). Each slice of real bacon is at a minimum 3 grams (50%) fat, and 3 grams (50%) protein. No carbs there, either.
So, if you’re struggling with your weight loss on a low carb diet . . . your first step should be “BLT” it!
“You want me to eat WHAT?! But that’s . . . ,it’s . . . FAT, really?”
” Yes, it is.”
Every day, instruction to my patients is initially seen as Food Pyramid heresy and My Plate iconoclasm. Yes, I want you to flip the Food Pyramid on its head, and push everything off My Plate and fill it with fat. . . Really. . . Yes, I do.
I was counseled by many school professors over the years that there are two things you should avoid talking about: Religion & Politics. The ketogenic or low carbohydrate dietary conversation involves both. “Fat Phobia” is a Religion. We have demonized fat and sainted the treadmill. You see, fat got a bad wrap when the bomb calorimeter was invented. We realized that there was twice as much energy found in fat that there was in carbohydrate or protein. Early nutritionists, understanding that heat is a form of energy, and realizing that energy is conserved, found that food substrates contain a set amount of energy that can be measured in a closed environment. Naturally, the Law of Thermodynamics got applied to lend understanding in how people gain or loose weight. We coined the term “you are what you eat” based upon our understanding of the Laws of Thermodynamics. The calorie became “king.”
1 gram of carbohydrate = 4 kcal
1 gram of protein = 4 kcal
1 gram of fat = 9 kcal
For the last sixty years (an entire generation of humans) we have based our diet around the calorimetry of food and have labeled them as good or bad based upon calories. To loose weight, we are taught, you either have to eat food containing fewer calories (fat has the most calories per volume so it must be bad!) or burn it off faster than you take it in (did you go exercise at that new gym next door), right? Wrong.
First, you and I are not bomb calorimeters. We are not closed systems. We harbor variable levels of symbiotic bacteria (these also burn fuel at variable rates) and our body temperatures fluctuate to regulate other enzymatic and hormonal processes.
Second, bomb calorimetery functions on the premise that volumes are also held at a constant. Human volume and density change daily. Simple chemistry tells us that volume = mass / density. The average human mass fluctuates by 5lbs every day and our density changes based upon our hydration status (the amount of water we drink). Because these two variables are not constant in a human being, it is impossible to correctly apply the Laws of Thermodynamics to the human body and accurately predict weight gain or loss.
Third, hormones! (Anyone married to a pregnant female understands that nothing is as it seems when hormones are involved.) We have a plethora of hormones that change the rate in which fuels are burned or stored in the human body. Our GI flora (symbiotic bacteria in the human gastrointestinal tract) are also affected by hormones and do not have set rates of fuel use or breakdown. What this means is that you and I process food at different rates and derive different levels of energy and fuel from the same donut. Genetics plays a leading role in how these hormones are used and turned on and off. Fat is burned or stored in the body based on a hormonal mechanism I described in a previous post you can read here.
Asking patients to reduce carbohydrate intake to less than 20 grams per day and increasing fat intake to up to 70% of total caloric intake is essentially 20th century nutritional apostasy.
The dietary concepts from the Food Pyramid and My Plate have been embraced by our country for over sixty years. Changing our views on these as a country will be for many like changing religions. For those of us “with eyes to see and ears to hear” our work is cut out for us.
Did you fall off the low-carbohydrate wagon this week? Did those donuts just call out your name as you walked by the bakery in the grocery store? Maybe you feel like you were shot out of the carbohydrate cannon, landing in the nearby Potato County? If so, you probably had a relapse. You were doing so well, then all the sudden, your will-power caved.
Relapse is not uncommon when making a dietary lifestyle change. What causes relapse? I often see people relapse back to the Standard American Diet, the SAD diet, because of a number of reasons.
First, it is important to recognize that there are a milieu of neuro-hormones that drive hunger cravings or suppression. Anything that triggers a change in these hormone levels can cause the carbohydrate cravings to kick in . . . and you find yourself stuffing yourself with “carbage.”
Second, is boredom. Many people find an increased nervousness when they get bored. They find that eating, with it’s calming parasympathetic nervous system effect, diminish the nervousness that arises out of boredom. They often create a near Pavlov’s type trigger to eat when they experience boredom and it is quickly interpreted as hunger. There is actually a release of endorphin associated with eating and chewing that suppresses stress and or anxiety. Reduction of stress, exercise, and journal writing have been found to help patient’s reduce the food cravings associated with boredom. It is important to have “rescue foods” like string cheese, a handful of almonds, beef jerky, or “fat bombs” available that can be used when you experience these symptoms.
Following the line of triggers, Pavlov demonstrated that repeated actions associated with rewarding consequences will form a physiologic trigger. Frequently. our desire to eat carbohydrates (“carb cravings”) are often tied to triggers. For example, growing up in my home as a child, our family frequently would relax by watching prime-time television while eating a large bowl of popcorn and a Pepsi. To this day, whenever I turn on the television in the evening, I get cravings for carbohydrates. It is important to look at what you were doing or what was going on around you at the time the craving occurred. Substitution of foods has helped to solve these cravings by replacing the popcorn and Pepsi with pork rinds and Diet Dr. Pepper. (Don’t cringe, pork rinds and guacamole tastes fantastic and is a very low carbohydrate substitute that works for me.)
Lastly, many patients fall off the wagon when they visit or have a meal with family. They are often made to feel guilty if they don’t eat Aunt Velda’s homemade chocolate chip cookies. They are afraid of offending their relatives if they don’t partake of those tasty cookies. The challenge is that cheating by eating the cookies causes an insulin spike and leads to 24-72 hours of carbohydrate cravings thereafter. Are those cookies worth 72 hours of carbohydrate cravings? Maybe. But it is important to consider helping Aunt Velda to understand what those cookies will do to you, and that you still care for Aunt Velda even if you don’t eat her chocolate chip cookies.
In many families, food is often associated with love. “If you don’t eat the food I made for you, you don’t really love me” is an underlying tone that can be found in many family dynamics that I see in my office. Some times bringing your own low-carb chocolate chip cookies, and offering one to Aunt Velda, will stimulate a conversation about your dietary changes and diffuse the guilt and offence that might arise.
Often, knowing what will cause you to fall off the wagon, helps to keep you on the wagon. What challenges have you had staying on the wagon?
Many patients come to my office desiring to loose weight, but complain of no self-control. They feel they cannot loose weight because they don’t have the willpower. Willpower, or self-control, is an elusive and mysterious thing. “If only I had more self-control,” I hear people say, “I could . . . ” exercise regularly, eat right, avoid drugs and alcohol, save for retirement, stop procrastinating, achieve a noble goal, or loose weight. A 2011 American Psychological Association study reveals that almost 30% of those interviewed felt that lack of willpower was the greatest barrier to making a change in any of these areas.
So what is “willpower” or “self-control?” It is the ability to resist short-term temptations in order to fulfill a long-term goal.
I meet and work with people every day who feel they have no willpower. In actuality, will power and self-control are learned behaviors that develop over time. Anyone can have willpower, you just have to understand how willpower in certain areas can be strengthened and what makes it weak. In fact, a 2005 study showed that self-discipline or willpower was more important than IQ in academic successes. This study also found that increased self-discipline lead to less binge eating, higher self-esteem, higher grade point averages, better relationship skills and less alcoholism. Fascinating isn’t it!?
The answer can be found in a quote from Henry P Liddon, “What we do upon some great occasion will probably depend on what we already are; and what we are will be the result of previous years of self-discipline.” This means that willpower or self-control can be learned or improved. How, you ask?
First, you must establish and write down a reason or motivation for change. In addition, that change must fulfill a clear goal. Just wanting to loose weight isn’t good enough. You have to be motivated because of a consequence that arises from the obesity or overweight. And, you “loosing weight” isn’t a clear goal. You must set a weight reduction goal. It has to be clearly written down with your motivational reason. Willpower or self-control cannot begin to form until these two steps occur.
Second, you must begin to monitor your behavior toward that goal. When it comes to weight loss, I ask every one of my patient’s to keep a diet journal. In this journal they are asked to write down every thing they eat and drink. The night before, they are to write down their plan for tomorrow’s meals, then the next evening, they account for their success or failure by journaling on that same page what they actually ate and drank, then after comparing what they did, they plan for tomorrow and journal why they were successful or why they weren’t. It’s the last part that is so powerful, a short 3-5 minutes of self-introspection. Self-introspection is the key to behavioral change. It is the key that allows a person to see their habits and then make very small changes that break bad habits, solidify good habits and strengthens willpower.
Third, willpower is developed over time. It is developed by being accountable to ones-self on very little things every single day. But it MUST be written down. If I planned to eat bacon and eggs for breakfast and I didn’t, why? When I look at my day, I may realize that I went to bed too late to get up early and cook bacon and eggs. So, instead, I ate a yogurt that was in the fridge. I am accountable to myself. If I plan to eat bacon and eggs tomorrow, I must either go to bed earlier, prepare them the night before, or throw out the yogurt . . . so not to be a temptation again. This is written down and I make a very small change tomorrow.
Over time, this self-introspection becomes easier and easier, to the point that you do it sub-consciously. It is this sub-conscious self-introspection and change will be seen by others as self-control or willpower. Just like a working or strengthening a muscle, recording short goals and and accounting for them makes your self-discipline stronger. The self-discipline muscle becomes more powerful. In time, a split second decision not to binge on that piece of cake will be seen as strong willpower by those around you. You’ll recognize that it’s just flexing your self-discipline muscle.
So, my next question to you is . . . where’s your diet journal?
While on the 2014 Low-Carb Cruise a few weeks ago, I had the wonderful pleasure of being interviewed by “N=1 Health‘s” Howard Harkness. We had very nice conversation and discussed a number of topics relating to obesity medicine, weight loss, carbohydrate restriction and some of the history of medicine. Take a look at the interview here on N=1 Health.
How are your stress levels lately? Are you struggling with your finances? Struggling with your job? Do you have troubles in your personal relationships? Are you carrying a heavy load in school? Do you have a horse that just won’t behave?
Many of my patients will routinely experience weight loss plateaus due to stress. Most of them want to know how and why this occurs. The simple answer is this: our bodies are designed with a “fight or flight” response.
If you’re in the woods and you stumble upon a bear, the sudden recognition of significant danger will stimulate an immediate release of protective hormones into your blood stream including adrenaline and cortisol. (Your brain also know that those extra few donuts you ate will make you quite the tasty treat for the bear.)
Fight or Flight Causes Glucose in the Blood Stream
Adrenaline increased your heart rate, dilates the blood vessels to your muscles and increases your respiratory rate. Cortisol is the hormone that stimulates increased glycogen release from the liver. Glycogen is a form of sugar made available so that you can immediately fight the bear or run from the bear. The glycogen response raises your insulin level so that that fuel can be pulled right into the cells needing it. The adrenalin and cortisol, among other hormones, are released so that blood can be shunted from your stomach and intestines to your muscles and brain to more effectively enable you to finish fighting the bear, or out run that drooling growling bear hot on your heels.
Modern Bears
Most of us will never “stumble across a bear.” However, your boss may confront you about how you handled a recent assignment or may drop an extra pile of work on your desk. You may run short on your finances this month, have a serious disagreement with your significant other, or someone may cut you off in traffic causing a near accident. Any or all of these stimulate the identical “fight or flight” response. Whether it is an actual bear or the stress from traffic, the same adrenalin and cortisol response occurs.
Chronic Cortisol Release & Weight Gain
How does that keep you from loosing weight? The elevated cortisol causes a cascade effect raising your insulin levels. Insulin will remain effectively elevated in the blood stream for the next 2-12 hours. Insulin is the primary hormone driving and stimulating weight gain. If you’ve had 2 or 3 stressful events throughout the day, and you have not had the opportunity to physically burn off these stress response hormones, your body will store and/or continue to gain weight throughout the entire day. If you have been trying to loose weight, the spike in the insulin from this cortisol cascade halts the weight burning process and may actually bump you out of ketosis (the process by which we burn fat as the primary fuel source) for the next 4-12 hours.
Mitigating Daily Stress
How do you prevent this from happening? A simple 15-20 minute walk 3-5 times per week is enough to decrease the stress hormone surge that occurs from a “fight or flight” response. Any regular exercise program will decrease these stress hormones. Adequate sleep also decreases these hormones.
Berberine, the active ingredient in tumeric, is also helpful in controlling blood sugar spikes and helping those with insulin resistance to handle stress and inflammation. I’ve been using berberine daily for years personally and with many of my patients. I love it so much, I designed my own formulation. You can find it along with my other supplement line at ketoliving.com.
If your job, school or life is stressful, incorporating an exercise program as simple as a daily walk for 15-20 minutes per day will keep the proverbial “bear in the woods” from catching up to you because of your weight. Controlling your blood sugar is the other key. The correct diet and supplements play a huge role combined with exercise.
Check out my diet page if you’d like a copy of my ketogenic dietary program. Check out my YouTube page for hundreds of free videos and DocMuscles.Locals.com for additional information for my followers. And, look at my membership programs available here.
I love chocolate chip cookies! However, over the last seven years, as I have followed a low carbohydrate diet I have not been able to indulge my chocolate chip cookie craving — until recently.
My gorgeous and very ingeniousness wife has perfected her chocolate chip cookie recipe and – Oh, WOW . . .are they good.
Warm, tasty chocolate chip cookies that are actually good for you, served up by a beautiful blond in a very cute apron. . . I think this is what heaven is like.
Here is a snapshot of the remaining batch my wife made at our house the other day before they got eaten. Boy, are they good. Here is the recipe:
Low Carbohydrate Chocolate Chip Cookies
1 tsp vanilla
2 eggs
2 sticks (1 cup) of butter, softened
1/2 cup Sweet Perfection
1/4 cup erythritol
1/4 cup Just Like Sugar (chicory root sweetener)
1 tsp salt
1 tsp baking soda
1 tsp baking powder
1 1/2 cup almond flour
1 cup coconut flour
1/2 cup Carbalose flour
2 ChocoPerfection Milk Chocolate bars chopped
Mix the vanilla, eggs, butter and sweeteners until creamy or fluffy. Add in all dry ingredients and mix. Add chocolate and mix. Place dough on parchment paper covered cookie sheets in 2 tsp sized scoops.
As a bariatrician, I think about fat all the time. I guess you could say I have a lot of “fat thoughts.”
I frequently hear patient’s tell me, “Dr. Nally, I’m eating RIGHT, but I’m just NOT losing weight!”
If you’re not losing weight, your not eating correctly. 99% of your weight loss success is related to your diet. We have been poorly misinformed over last 40 years as to what a “correct” diet contains. We’ve been told to follow a low fat diet for the last 40-50 years. However, it is very apparent as patient’s follow a low fat diet that only a small percentage of them have success in weight loss, and the majority actually gains more weight and remains significantly hungry. When you look at the body’s physiology, fat restriction only stimulates increased hunger. The intake of any form of carbohydrate, whether that be simple or complex, stimulates an insulin response. Based on our genetics, that insulin response can be variable. some of us respond normally and others respond with between 2-10 times the normal insulin surge. Insulin is actually the hormone that drives weight loss or weight gain.
You and I will not be able to effectively lose weight until we control the response of insulin, and this can only be done through carbohydrate restriction.
A recent study published in the Annals of Internal Medicine demonstrate significant improvement in overall inflammation in type II diabetic patients following a carbohydrate restricted diet versus a low fat calorie restricted diet. Another bit of proof demonstrating what I’ve been seeing in my office over the last 8 years. The study reveals significant improvement in glycemic (blood sugar) control in those following a low carbohydrate diet as well as significant lowering of C-reactive protein, IL-1 and IL-6 over those following a low fat diet. You can see the study here.
A common problem that arises in patients with diabetes is that of kidney disease or “nephropathy.” Nephropathy is defined as damage to or disease of the filtering system of the kidney. In diabetic patients, they commonly begin to loose the ability to adequately filter and retain microscopic protein needed in the body. As the blood sugar and insulin levels progressively rise over time, damage to the delicate filtering system of the kidneys occur.
Very impressive results revealing improved kidney function were found in both Type I and Type II diabetic mice placed on a low carbohydrate, or ketogenic, diet in just and 8 week period of time. The nephropathy (reduced passage of protein through the kidneys) was completely reversed in all the mice. This is the first in what I suspect will be a series of articles showing that ketogenic diets have significant effect on reversal of age related and diabetic tissue damage. See the article here.